Montage of images to demonstrate the speleology and sedimentology of the cave from the wide and high entrance to the narrower and smaller passage that lead to the confined fossil chamber.
Human evolution has never resembled the tidy, linear progression that creationists so often attack as though it were evolutionary theory. It was a branching and sometimes reticulated history in which different human populations dispersed, became isolated, adapted to different environments and occasionally occupied neighbouring regions at the same time.
Two complementary studies, published open access in Nature, have now added an unexpected late chapter to that history. They show that Homo erectus survived on the East Asian mainland much more recently than previously demonstrated and occupied an environment once thought to have been beyond its capabilities: the dense tropical rainforests of southern China.
Homo erectus was one of the most successful and long-lasting human species. It first appeared about 1.9 million years ago, spread from Africa across much of Eurasia and persisted somewhere in its enormous geographical range until roughly 108,000 years ago. Its anatomy, including relatively modern human-like body proportions, was well suited to travelling long distances, and its populations survived through repeated climatic and environmental changes for considerably longer than Homo sapiens has existed so far.
Fossil Teeth^ Tiny Archives of Ancestry, Environment and Migration. A fossil tooth may appear less informative than a skull or complete skeleton, but teeth are among the most valuable sources of evidence in palaeoanthropology. Their exceptional hardness allows them to survive conditions that destroy most other biological material, while their shapes, proteins and chemical composition preserve different parts of an individual’s history.Most of what we know about East Asian Homo erectus, however, comes from an incomplete and geographically uneven fossil record. Until now, the youngest securely dated mainland Chinese specimens attributed to the species were approximately 400,000 years old. Later populations were known from the Indonesian island of Java, but it remained uncertain how long Homo erectus survived on the Asian mainland or what kinds of environment it could exploit.
Unlike bone, which is continually broken down and rebuilt during life, tooth enamel does not remodel after it has formed. Chemical signals incorporated during childhood can therefore remain locked inside it for hundreds of thousands—or even millions—of years.
The Guangxi teeth were investigated using several complementary techniques. Each addressed a different question:
Evidence What it can reveal External crown and root shape Similarities and differences between hominin species and populations Enamel–dentine junction Internal tooth morphology that is less affected by wear than the outer crown Ancient enamel proteins Molecular evidence of evolutionary relationships when DNA has not survived Uranium-series and electron-spin-resonance measurements Constraints upon how long the tooth has been buried Stable isotopes Information about vegetation, diet, climate and habitat Trace elements Chemical changes recorded while the tooth was growing Strontium isotopes The geological regions from which childhood food and water were obtained
Identifying the owner from tooth shape
Different hominin populations did not possess completely interchangeable teeth. Their crowns, roots, cusps and internal structures developed in inherited patterns that can be compared statistically with those of securely identified fossils.
Wear may remove much of a tooth’s visible surface, so researchers also use micro-computed tomography to examine the boundary between enamel and dentine. This enamel–dentine junction preserves the original shape of the developing crown and can retain useful anatomical features after the exposed enamel has been worn down.
Geometric morphometrics allows these shapes to be represented by landmarks and compared quantitatively. In the Guangxi study, the internal and external morphology of eight teeth placed them within or close to the variation previously documented in Asian Homo erectus.
Morphology alone is not infallible. Related populations can retain similar ancestral features, while individuals belonging to the same species naturally vary. This is why molecular evidence from ancient proteins was particularly important.
Palaeoproteomics: molecular evidence without ancient DNA
DNA is chemically fragile. It survives best in cold, dry and stable conditions, but degrades rapidly in the heat and humidity of tropical environments. The absence of recoverable DNA from an ancient tropical fossil is therefore expected and says nothing about whether the organism once possessed it.
Proteins can survive much longer, particularly when protected within dental enamel. Palaeoproteomics identifies fragments of those proteins and reconstructs parts of their amino-acid sequences. Inherited differences between sequences can then be compared with proteins recovered from other fossils.
Five of the Guangxi teeth retained endogenous enamel proteins. Four contained a derived amino-acid form of ameloblastin previously detected in Chinese Homo erectus. Their morphology independently supported the same identification, allowing eight of the nine teeth to be attributed to the species.
Protein evidence is less detailed than a complete genome. It usually contains far fewer variable positions and cannot identify every relationship between populations. It nevertheless provides genuine molecular evidence where DNA preservation has reached its limit.
The fifth protein-bearing tooth, PA1796, lacked the Homo erectus ameloblastin signature and also differed morphologically from Homo erectus, Neanderthals and Homo sapiens. It may have belonged to another hominin lineage, but the available evidence is insufficient to identify that lineage confidently.
Dating the teeth and their deposits
Scientists did not obtain the Guangxi chronology from a single measurement. They dated fossil teeth, cave carbonates and sediment grains using five complementary methods and incorporated 43 results into Bayesian age models.
Uranium-series dating measures radioactive changes involving uranium absorbed after burial. Electron-spin-resonance dating measures trapped electrical charges that accumulate within tooth enamel through exposure to natural radiation. Luminescence methods estimate when mineral grains in the surrounding sediment were last exposed to light, while carbonate flowstones provide additional constraints upon the cave sequence.
Every method has assumptions and uncertainties, but methods based upon different physical processes can be checked against one another. Their combined results placed the two cave assemblages between approximately 324,000 and 184,000 years ago.
Reconstructing habitat from isotope chemistry
Plants using different photosynthetic pathways possess distinctive carbon-isotope ratios. Those signals pass into herbivores that eat the plants and then into predators or omnivores that consume material from the same food web. Carbon preserved in tooth enamel can therefore help distinguish open grasslands from wooded or closed-canopy environments.
The hominin teeth were analysed alongside teeth from the other animals found in the caves. Stable-isotope measurements, the associated fauna and temperature evidence from the cave deposits collectively indicated a predominantly closed, tropical rainforest ecosystem rather than an open savannah.
This does not reveal precisely which fruits, plants or animals the hominins ate. It reconstructs the broader ecological system from which their food and water were obtained.
Strontium as a record of childhood movement
Strontium occurs naturally in rocks and enters soil, water, plants and animals without substantially changing its isotope ratio. Because different geological formations possess different ratios, a geographical map of biologically available strontium can be used as a chemical map of the landscape.
As a child’s permanent teeth form, strontium from food and water becomes incorporated into their enamel. If the enamel signature differs from that of the locality where the tooth was eventually buried, the individual may have moved between geological regions or obtained food from outside the immediate area.
The strontium values measured in four Guangxi Homo erectus teeth indicate either movement through geologically distinct areas during childhood or the consumption of resources brought from several locations. Comparison with a regional strontium map suggests potentially extensive mobility, but it cannot reveal an exact route, season or reason for travelling.
Why several lines of evidence matter
No single tooth measurement supplies the entire story. Morphology helps identify the hominin; proteins provide molecular support; radioactive and luminescence methods constrain its age; stable isotopes reconstruct its environment; and strontium provides evidence about childhood geography.
These methods depend upon different anatomical, chemical and physical processes. Their convergence makes the result much stronger than any one measurement considered alone. The Guangxi teeth are therefore not merely isolated fragments. They are miniature archives recording ancestry, deep time, rainforest ecology and the movements of an extinct human population.
The new evidence comes from Naxian and Baxian caves, situated about 15 kilometres apart in the karst landscape of Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region in southern China. Excavations recovered nine hominin teeth together with more than 18,000 other mammalian fossils, including remains of apes, elephants, rhinoceroses and bovids.
In the first Nature paper, an international team led by Wei Liao, Clément Zanolli, Ragnheiður Diljá Ásmundsdóttir and colleagues examined the teeth using external morphology, micro-computed tomography, geometric morphometrics and palaeoproteomics—the recovery and analysis of ancient proteins.
Ancient DNA rarely survives for hundreds of thousands of years in warm, humid tropical environments. Dental-enamel proteins are more durable, however, and can preserve molecular evidence long after DNA has degraded beyond recovery. The researchers recovered endogenous enamel proteins from all five teeth selected for molecular analysis.
Four of those teeth contained a derived form of the enamel protein ameloblastin previously identified in Chinese Homo erectus. Their protein sequences also differed at another position from the earlier Chinese specimens, suggesting that the Guangxi fossils represent a previously unsampled population rather than merely replicating the molecular pattern already known elsewhere. Tooth shape and internal structure supported the attribution of these four and four additional teeth to Homo erectus.
The ninth tooth, designated PA1796, produced a more intriguing result. Its morphology differed from that of Homo erectus, Neanderthals and modern humans, and it lacked the protein variant used to identify the other teeth as Homo erectus. It may therefore represent a second human lineage occupying the region at approximately the same time.
The researchers discuss a possible relationship with the Asian lineage often called Homo longi and associated with Denisovans, but the tooth cannot presently be assigned to that lineage with confidence. It is evidence of an unidentified hominin, not a Denisovan diagnosis. Nevertheless, its presence reinforces the emerging picture of Middle Pleistocene Asia as a region occupied by several evolving human populations rather than by one species simply replacing another in an orderly procession.
Establishing when these populations lived required much more than assigning the teeth a convenient date. In the accompanying Nature study, Kira Westaway, Renaud Joannes-Boyau and colleagues combined 43 radiometric measurements obtained through five dating techniques.
These included luminescence dating of feldspar and quartz grains, uranium-series dating of fossil teeth and cave carbonates, and combined uranium-series and electron-spin-resonance dating of teeth. The results were integrated using two Bayesian chronological models. Together, they place the cave deposits between approximately 324,000 and 184,000 years ago, making these the youngest securely dated Homo erectus fossils yet identified on the East Asian mainland.
The teeth also recorded information about the environment in which their owners lived. Stable and clumped isotopes, trace elements, animal fossils and sediment temperatures independently point towards a closed-canopy tropical rainforest rather than the open grassland and woodland mosaics conventionally associated with Homo erectus.
Rainforests present substantial challenges to large terrestrial primates. Dense vegetation restricts visibility and movement, while edible resources can be scattered, seasonal and difficult to locate. The evidence from Guangxi therefore challenges the assumption that only Homo sapiens possessed sufficient behavioural flexibility to live persistently in such environments.
Strontium isotopes preserved in four of the teeth add a further possibility. Because local rocks, soils, water and food possess geographically variable strontium signatures, tooth enamel formed during childhood can preserve evidence of where an individual obtained its food. The Guangxi signatures indicate either movement between geologically different regions or the acquisition of resources from several areas while the teeth were forming.
Comparison with a regional strontium map suggests that some individuals may have ranged across substantial distances, potentially using corridors extending towards northern Vietnam and mainland Southeast Asia. The evidence is limited and cannot reconstruct particular journeys, seasons or motives, but it is inconsistent with a population confined permanently to the immediate surroundings of the two caves.
The resulting picture is of a late-surviving Homo erectus population that was neither ecologically restricted nor behaviourally static. These people persisted in tropical forest, travelled or obtained resources across geologically varied landscapes and may have shared the wider region with another human lineage.
None of this resembles the creationist fiction of separately manufactured, immutable human “kinds”. Nor can hundreds of thousands of years of population dispersal, adaptation and coexistence be compressed into the few generations supposedly available after a recent global flood. Five independent dating systems, fossil anatomy, ancient proteins, isotope chemistry and environmental evidence all converge upon the same natural history.
The researchers did not need to invoke magic to explain any part of it. Inheritance, mutation, population separation, migration, adaptation and extinction are sufficient. Once again, the evidence reveals a complex evolutionary past that creationism neither predicted nor has any coherent mechanism to explain.
The Nature Portfolio research release summarises both studies and their significance:
Palaeontology: The last-known occurrence of Homo erectus on the Asian mainland (Nature)
Homo erectus remained present in mainland Asia for longer than previously thought, according to the discovery of teeth from two caves in southern China, dated to around 324,000–184,000 years ago. The findings, reported in two Nature papers, place these ancient humans in the region more recently than the previously established timeline of around 400,000 years ago. Fossil evidence indicates that this H. erectus population lived in rainforests, an environment formerly only thought suitable for modern humans (Homo sapiens). These results challenge assumptions about the behavioural limitations of H. erectus. Homo erectus was one of the longest-surviving hominin species and is known to have been present across Africa to eastern Eurasia between around 1.9 million years ago and 108,000 years ago. However, there are gaps in the fossil record for the Chinese mainland, making it difficult to understand its adaption capabilities in this region. New evidence helps to address these gaps.
Nine hominin teeth — as well as other fossils — were recovered from two caves, Baxian and Naxian, which are located around 15 km apart in the Guangxi province of southern China. Radiometric dating of the fossils and surrounding sediments indicate that these hominins were present around 324,000–184,000 years ago. Over 18,000 mammalian fossils were also recovered, including species of ape, elephant, rhinoceros, and ancient bovid.
Frido Welker and colleagues studied the physical characteristics of the teeth and analysed ancient proteins from five of them; of these five, they identified four as belonging to H. erectus. As these proteins differ from those found in other H. erectus remains in China, the new specimens may represent a previously unsampled population. One of the teeth was found to be morphologically distinct from H. erectus, Neanderthals, and modern humans, and lacked the H. erectus protein signature, which suggests that at least two hominin lineages were present in the region at this time.
In a separate study, Kira Westaway and colleagues analysed the hominin and animal teeth to reconstruct the environment in which the hominins lived. Trace elements found in the teeth can give clues as to the food eaten by hominins and other animals, which can help to determine both the habitat they are likely to have lived in and how they behaved. Elements detected in the H. erectus teeth indicate that they found food in tropical, rainforest-like ecosystems, previously thought to have been the sole domain of H. sapiens. Trace elements associated with regions as far away as northern Vietnam suggest that these H. erectus individuals moved across large areas.
Together, the findings reveal that H. erectus occupied southern China for longer than previously reported, and offer new insights into the type of habitat it lived in. Mainland Asia may represent an important region for studying the evolution and behaviour of the last-surviving H. erectus, the authors conclude.
Publications:Liao, W., Zanolli, C., Ásmundsdóttir, R.D. et al.
Evidence for late Middle Pleistocene Homo erectus in mainland East Asia.
Nature (2026). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11271-3
Westaway, K.E., Joannes-Boyau, R., Liao, W. et al.
Rainforest adaptation in late Homo erectus from southern China.
Nature (2026). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-026-11155-6
The importance of these discoveries lies not in any single spectacular fossil but in the convergence of several independent forms of evidence. Tooth anatomy identifies eight specimens as Homo erectus; ancient enamel proteins provide molecular support for that identification; 43 measurements obtained through five dating methods establish their Middle Pleistocene age; and isotope chemistry, associated animal fossils and cave sediments reconstruct the environment in which these people lived.
The conclusions are appropriately specific. The researchers have not shown that every Homo erectus population lived in rainforest, nor have they reconstructed the precise journeys or diets of the Guangxi individuals. The strontium evidence indicates movement between geologically different regions or the acquisition of non-local resources, but cannot distinguish between seasonal migration, occasional long-distance travel and exchange between groups.
Similarly, the anomalous tooth PA1796 does not establish that its owner was a Denisovan or member of Homo longi. Its morphology and enamel proteins show that it does not fit comfortably within Homo erectus, Neanderthals or modern humans, but the evidence is insufficient for a secure taxonomic identification. What it does demonstrate is that the evolutionary diversity of Middle Pleistocene Asia remains incompletely sampled.
That uncertainty does not weaken the evolutionary account. On the contrary, it is exactly what should be expected from a sparsely preserved history containing several geographically dispersed and sometimes overlapping human populations. Evolutionary biology does not predict a neat sequence in which one completely formed species disappears before another appears. Populations can persist in refuges, expand into new habitats, divide, reconnect and coexist with related lineages.
The Guangxi Homo erectus population also challenges the old portrayal of the species as behaviourally restricted and incapable of exploiting complex environments. These people survived in closed tropical forest, obtained resources across a varied landscape and apparently remained in southern China long after securely identified Homo erectus had disappeared from other mainland sites. Their evolutionary success depended upon ecological flexibility, not upon remaining unchanged within a habitat supposedly assigned to them at creation.
Creationists may attempt to absorb all these hominins into an undefined “human kind”, but that manoeuvre explains nothing. The category would have to include populations separated across Africa and Eurasia for more than a million years, possessing recognisably different anatomical and molecular characteristics, adapting to different environments and sometimes existing alongside other human lineages. It would merely rename the evolutionary history while refusing to account for it.
Nor can the chronology be compressed into a few generations following a mythical global flood. The Guangxi deposits are between approximately 324,000 and 184,000 years old, and that range was not produced by one arbitrary measurement. Luminescence, uranium-series and electron-spin-resonance methods, applied to different materials and integrated through Bayesian modelling, independently constrain the same ancient sequence.
The fossils therefore record a world populated by several evolving human lineages hundreds of thousands of years before Young-Earth creationists believe the Universe existed. Their teeth preserve inherited anatomy, evolutionary proteins, environmental chemistry and evidence of childhood movement—all of it consistent with common descent, population divergence and adaptation over deep time.
No supernatural intervention is required to explain any part of this history. Mutation and inheritance produced variation; migration carried populations into new regions; isolation allowed them to diverge; natural selection favoured traits and behaviours suited to local conditions; and extinction eventually removed most of those lineages. What remained in the Guangxi caves was not evidence of separately created, immutable kinds, but a fragment of the complex and branching evolutionary history of humanity.
Advertisement
All titles available in paperback, hardcover, ebook for Kindle and audio format.
Prices correct at time of publication. for current prices.




















No comments:
Post a Comment
Obscene, threatening or obnoxious messages, preaching, abuse and spam will be removed, as will anything by known Internet trolls and stalkers, by known sock-puppet accounts and anything not connected with the post,
A claim made without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. Remember: your opinion is not an established fact unless corroborated.