Rosa Rubicondior: Creationism Refuted - Most Complete Fossil Early Canid - From 30 Million Years Before 'Creation Week'

Friday, 31 July 2026

Creationism Refuted - Most Complete Fossil Early Canid - From 30 Million Years Before 'Creation Week'

Mesocyon coryphaeus in its natural setting

AI-generated image (ChatGPT 5.6 Sol)

Mesocyon coryphaeus hunting.

Image credit: Roger Witter

Most complete skeleton of 30 million-year-old dog discovered | University of Michigan News

My last blog post concerned a 210-million-year-old, gap-filling dinosaur from Zimbabwe that is helping palaeontologists to reconstruct the early evolution and dispersal of dinosaurs.

This post concerns another gap-filling fossil, although one from much closer to the present—just 30 million years ago. It is a remarkably complete skeleton of the early canid Mesocyon coryphaeus, one of the most complete pre-Ice Age canid skeletons yet found in North America.

This specimen fills a different sort of gap. Mesocyon coryphaeus, first named in 1879, is relatively common in the John Day Formation of Oregon, but it was previously known principally from skulls and teeth. Its postcranial skeleton—the bones behind the skull—had remained almost entirely unknown. The new specimen therefore fills an important anatomical gap in our understanding of how early canids moved, hunted and responded to the changing environments of Oligocene North America.

The fossil itself has had a curious history. It was collected during the late 1980s from land administered by the Bureau of Land Management near what is now the John Day Fossil Beds National Monument. Encased in a protective plaster jacket, it entered the monument’s collection after initially being mistaken for an oreodont—an extinct North American even-toed ungulate sometimes loosely described as resembling a mixture of sheep, camel and pig.

During the 1990s, the skull was separated from the surrounding rock for display, whereupon its teeth and cranial anatomy revealed that it was actually a canid. Park palaeontologists began exposing the remainder of the skeleton in 2012, but preparation continued intermittently for years. By the time the fossil was fully uncovered in 2022, more than 500 hours of painstaking preparation had been devoted to it.

University of Michigan palaeontologist Anne E. Kort, together with Jennifer Cavin of John Day Fossil Beds National Monument and Xiaoming Wang of the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County, formally described the specimen in a paper published online in the Journal of Paleontology on 29 May 2026.

Known as JODA 3366, the specimen includes a complete cranium, an almost complete vertebral column in front of the sacrum, all the major limb bones and parts of both the forefeet and hindfeet. Only the tail and portions of the hands and feet are missing. It even preserves part of the baculum, or penis bone, establishing beyond reasonable doubt that the animal was male.

Identification rests principally on the anatomy of the skull and teeth, but an additional clue was provided by a mushroom-shaped bone growth near the wrist on the left radius. This condition, known as hereditary osteochondroma, has also been found in about 60% of examined Oligocene specimens of the earlier canid Hesperocyon, as well as in several other early carnivorans. Its presence provides an unusual glimpse of an inherited disorder persisting in these ancient populations.

The earliest well-known canid, Hesperocyon gregarius, appeared in North America during the late Eocene, about 40 million years ago, and was probably close to the ancestry of all later canids. It was a small, scansorial animal—adapted for moving both on the ground and in trees—living when much of its habitat consisted of warm, closed-canopy forest.

By the time this Mesocyon lived, between 31.4 and 29.0 million years ago, global cooling had transformed much of that dense forest into a changing mosaic of subhumid woodland and semiarid shrubland. Later canids would become increasingly cursorial, evolving long limbs, elongated feet and stabilised joints suited to pursuing prey across increasingly open country. Mesocyon, however, shows that this transition was neither immediate nor a simple, linear progression.

Although roughly the size of a modern coyote, Mesocyon had a long body, short legs and unusually robust limb bones. The researchers estimate that it weighed about 14–15 kilograms, stood approximately 40 centimetres at the shoulder and measured around 80 centimetres from its snout to the base of its tail. Its relatively mobile spine may have allowed it to accelerate rapidly over short distances, but it lacked the specialised anatomy needed for the sustained running typical of most modern dogs.

Its elbow joints allowed greater rotation of the forearms than those of living canids, probably helping it to grapple with prey. This mobility may also have allowed it occasionally to climb, rather like a modern wolverine, although its limbs lacked the clear adaptations of a genuinely arboreal mammal. The authors therefore interpret it as primarily a ground-dwelling animal and, at most, an occasional and rather clumsy climber.

Its feet also retained an intermediate arrangement. The first metatarsal—the bone corresponding to the innermost toe—was much less reduced than in later canids, while several features of its ankles and limbs suggest that it normally adopted a semidigitigrade posture. In other words, it held its heel higher than a fully plantigrade animal such as a human or bear, but not as consistently high as a modern dog walking permanently on its toes. It may even have been able to switch temporarily to a more completely digitigrade stance.

Taken together, the evidence suggests that Mesocyon coryphaeus was a terrestrial ambush predator rather than a long-distance pursuit hunter. Its lifestyle was probably more like that of a large mustelid than a modern dog: approaching under cover, accelerating in a short burst and using its powerful forelimbs to seize small prey such as rodents, lagomorphs and hypertragulids—small, mouse-deer-like ruminants that lived on the forest floor.

Nor was Mesocyon a direct ancestor of modern wolves, foxes or domestic dogs. It belonged to Hesperocyoninae, an early radiation of canids whose entire lineage eventually became extinct, while living canids belong to a different branch, Caninae. Mesocyon was therefore not a rung on a ladder leading inexorably towards the modern dog, but a member of a collateral branch of the canid family tree that evolved its own successful way of life before disappearing without descendants.

That distinction matters because evolution is not a procession of progressively “improved” organisms marching towards a predetermined goal. It is a branching process in which populations inherit ancestral characteristics, acquire new modifications and adapt opportunistically to the conditions in which they live. Some branches diversify; others persist for millions of years and then become extinct. Mesocyon, with its mixture of retained climbing ability, semidigitigrade feet, robust limbs and specialised carnivorous teeth, is precisely the sort of mosaic that evolutionary theory predicts.

This is also why the familiar creationist demand for an unbroken procession of “missing links” is so fundamentally misconceived. The fossil record preserves fragments of a branching history, not a single-file parade towards modern “kinds”. Each new specimen such as JODA 3366 supplies another part of that history, allowing scientists to test increasingly detailed predictions about anatomy, ecology and evolutionary relationships. And, once again, when another gap in scientific knowledge is filled, there is no trace of supernatural creation hiding inside it—only more evidence of descent with modification.

The Canid Family Tree^ 40 Million Years of Evolution. The dog family, Canidae, originated in North America during the late Eocene, about 40 million years ago. For most of its early history it remained confined to that continent, where it underwent three major, overlapping evolutionary radiations. Two of these branches became completely extinct; every living canid belongs to the third.

Hesperocyoninae: the first radiation

Late Eocene to middle Miocene, approximately 40–15 million years ago

The earliest radiation consisted of the hesperocyonines, generally small, long-bodied animals retaining relatively flexible limbs and some ability to climb. Hesperocyon, one of the earliest well-known members, was probably close to the ancestry of all later canids.

As North American habitats changed, hesperocyonines diversified into numerous forms ranging from small omnivores to larger, specialised carnivores. Mesocyon belonged to one of these branches, together with later genera such as Enhydrocyon. It was therefore a collateral relative of the ancestors of modern dogs, not itself their direct ancestor.

Hesperocyonines declined as they encountered increasing competition from other canids and from cats arriving from Eurasia. The entire subfamily eventually became extinct.

Borophaginae: the “bone-crushing dogs”

Early Oligocene to late Pliocene, approximately 34–2.5 million years ago

The borophagines began as small, fox-sized canids but radiated into a wide variety of omnivores and predators. Some later members, including Epicyon and Borophagus, developed massive skulls, powerful jaws and enlarged premolars capable of crushing bone. Superficially, these animals resembled modern hyenas, although hyenas belong to the cat-like branch of Carnivora and are not canids.

Some borophagines became among the largest canids ever to evolve. Nevertheless, this once-successful radiation also disappeared, probably through a combination of ecological specialisation, environmental change and competition from cats and the increasingly cursorial Caninae.

Caninae: the surviving radiation

Early Oligocene to the present, beginning about 34 million years ago

The earliest canines included Leptocyon, a small, lightly built, fox-like animal. Caninae remained comparatively inconspicuous for much of the Oligocene and early Miocene but later benefited as open grasslands spread. Longer limbs, elongated metapodials, reduced first toes and more stabilised joints produced efficient digitigrade runners capable of travelling and pursuing prey over long distances.

Caninae is the only canid subfamily to survive. Its living members are commonly divided into three principal lineages:

Vulpini—the fox-like canids: true foxes such as the red, Arctic and fennec foxes, together with related forms. The precise placement of grey foxes and raccoon dogs varies somewhat among phylogenetic studies.

The true-wolf lineage: wolves, coyotes and jackals of the genus Canis, together with the dhole, Cuon alpinus, and African wild dog, Lycaon pictus. The domestic dog is a domesticated member of the grey-wolf lineage, not a separately created species.

Cerdocyonina—the South American canids: including the maned wolf, bush dog, crab-eating fox and the several species of Lycalopex, commonly called South American foxes despite being more closely related to wolf-like canids than to true foxes.

From North America to the world

Canids remained restricted to North America for most of their early evolution. Members of Caninae crossed into Eurasia through Beringia during the late Miocene, roughly 10–8 million years ago, and subsequently spread into Africa. Other canines entered South America when connections between the continents became available, with a major expansion following the formation of the Panamanian land bridge about 3 million years ago. They then underwent a remarkable radiation into the varied South American forms living today.

Australia’s dingoes arrived much later with humans and are descended from domesticated dogs. No native canid lineage ever reached Antarctica.

Repeated evolution, not a ladder

Canid history was not a steady ascent from Hesperocyon through Mesocyon to the modern wolf. Each of the three subfamilies independently produced larger predators, dietary specialists and increasingly carnivorous forms. Adaptations for long-distance running also appeared at different times and to different degrees as habitats became more open.

Mesocyon is important precisely because it preserves one of evolution’s discarded alternatives: a coyote-sized, heavily carnivorous canid that retained a short-legged, mustelid-like style of locomotion rather than becoming an endurance runner. Its lineage flourished for millions of years and then vanished.

The fossil and genetic evidence therefore reveal not separately created “dog kinds”, but a branching and repeatedly diversifying family tree—complete with inherited features, intermediate anatomies, ecological radiations and numerous extinct branches.

The paper in the Journal of Paleontology was accompanied by a news item in Michigan News:

Most complete skeleton of 30 million-year-old dog discovered
For decades, a 30 million-year-old-fossil sat entombed in rock in an Oregon museum collection. When it was first found, paleontologists thought it might be an early relative of sheep, camels and pigs whose fossilized skeletons are, in the researchers’ view, abundant.
Later, they realized it was an early dog fossil, and now, University of Michigan paleontologist Anne Kort has confirmed that it’s one of the most complete fossils of a pre-Ice Age dog found in North America, a canid called Mesocyon coryphaeus. In fact, the species, first named in 1879, had only been previously identified by single skulls.

Kort was tasked with describing the fossil as part of a special issue of the Journal of Paleontology, celebrating the 50th anniversary of John Day Fossil Beds National Monument, or JODA. She says the fossil was initially discovered in the late 1980s, near the monument in Oregon, on Bureau of Land Management lands.

At the time, paleontologists carefully extracted the fossil and its surrounding rock and wrapped it for protection in a plaster jacket. In the 1990s, researchers separated the head for display, then determining it was a kind of dog. Park paleontologists including Jennifer Cavin, co-author of the study, uncovered the rest of the skeleton in 2012, realizing how complete the skeleton was.

They thought at first it was an oreodont, which we like to call sheep-camel-pigs. This was the most magical, fun project to just be handed on a silver platter.

Anne E. Kurt, lead author
Museum of Paleontology University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
Michigan, USA.

The hip bone is connected to the … baculum

University of Michigan paleontologist Anne Kort identified a fossil as one of the most complete Mesocyon coryphaeus specimens found yet. Kort said the dog, which was about the size of a coyote, likely at least occasionally walked from heel to toe and was not adapted for running, whereas modern dogs walk on their tip toes and are adapted for running.

Image credit: Anne Kort
University of Michigan.

To establish that the fossil was indeed a dog, Kort says researchers typically would compare features to other dog fossils, such as the shape of the fossil’s teeth, the shape of the skull and other features. This particular fossil also had a hereditary bone growth on the end of its wrists called an osteochondroma, which is found in about 60% of the earliest dog fossils.

It’s just this really cool direct hereditary link that we wouldn’t normally find. This is another line of evidence, and that gives you an idea of how great this fossil is.

Anne E. Kurt.

The fossil itself is nearly complete, missing only the tail and parts of the hands and feet of the animal. The integrity of the fossil also meant that the researchers did not have to guess whether the specimen was male or female.

The other fun thing is, it even had the baculum, so, the penis bone. That means we definitely know this was a male.

Anne E. Kurt.

What the bones tell us

A fossil of Mesocyon coryphaeus was found on Bureau of Land Management land in the 1980s, near the John Day Fossil Beds National Monument.

Image credit: National Park Service. Mural created by Roger Witter.

Dogs first originated in North America about 40 million years ago, according to Kort. Their common ancestor is a canid called Hesperocyon. At the time, the North American continent’s terrain was composed of dense, rainforest-like forests, which meant that Hesperocyon was likely a “pretty good climber,” unlike dogs today, Kort says.

Mesocyon, Kort’s fossil, originated about 10 million years later, during a period of global cooling. The dense forests gave way to more open woodland and sometimes shrubland. Kort wanted to see if the Mesocyon fossil would have the same running adaptations as modern dogs.

The answer is pretty definitely no. Mesocyon also just has more robust bones in general. It’s shorter and stockier.

Anne E. Kurt.

The fossil’s elbow joining suggests that it could rotate its forearms, indicating the ability to grapple and climb, she says. The fossil shows that Mesocyon also still had its big toe, or what’s called the dew claw in contemporary dogs. This suggests Mesocyan was at least occasionally walking heel-down, instead of on its tip toes, like dogs do today.

Kort says the fossil holds one more lesson for us: When an animal goes extinct, its lineage is lost forever.

Kaori Chambers, University of Michigan graduate student in ecology and evolutionary biology, created an artistic representation of Mesocyon coryphaeus. U-M paleontologist Anne Kort identified a fossil as one of the most complete Mesocyon coryphaeus specimens found yet. The specimen was a fossil dog the size of a coyote.

Image credit: Kaori Chambers
University of Michigan.

This fossil is not our current dogs’ great-great-great uncle, because this whole line went fully extinct. And with that extinction, we did lose a whole kind of dog ecology that we just don’t see anymore. I think sometimes there’s an assumption that life finds a way if something goes extinct. It will be replaced, or something will magically bounce back. But evolution never finds a perfect fit, it finds good fits. So when we lose things, they’re gone forever. They’re never going to be perfectly replaced, and I think that’s an important lesson to take away when we’re thinking about extinctions today.

Anne E. Kurt.

JODA paleontologist Ted Fremd was the researcher who initially found the specimen, prioritized its collection and completed the initial round of preparation to remove the skull. JODA paleontologist Joshua Samuels directed Cavin to work on removing the fossil from its protective jacket in 2011. Nicholas Famoso, current chief paleontologist for JODA, suggested Kort work on the project. Xiaoming Wang, a researcher at the Natural History Museum of Los Angeles County, is a co-author of the study.

Publication:
Kort AE, Cavin J, Wang X.
Postcrania and locomotor function of Mesocyon coryphaeus (Canidae, Carnivora) from the Arikareean of North America.
Journal of Paleontology. Published online 2026:1-18. doi:10.1017/jpa.2026.10232

Abstract
Canids increased in cursoriality through the Cenozoic, as environments transitioned from closed-canopy forest to open grassland and steppe. Canids have evolved through a series of radiations since their origin in the Eocene, but it is unclear if cursorial adaptations appeared in the earliest of these radiations. In the middle Oligocene, the basal hesperocyonines ecologically diversified, and the coyote-sized Mesocyon coryphaeus exemplified the transition from smaller, omnivorous canids to larger, hypercarnivorous forms. M. coryphaeus is exclusively known from the John Day Formation of North America. Although M. coryphaeus is a relatively common fossil in this formation, first recognized in the late 19th century, no postcranial material from this species has ever been formally described. Here, we present a near-complete skeleton of M. coryphaeus, JODA 3366, which includes a complete cranium, near-complete presacral spine, all long bones, elements of both the manus and pes, and a baculum. The short, robust limbs, mobile elbow joint, and tarsal morphology of M. coryphaeus indicate that this species retained a plantigrade to semidigitigrade posture, similar to the earliest canid Hesperocyon, and lacked the cursorial adaptations found in more derived canids. Based on this morphology, we interpret M. coryphaeus as a terrestrial ambush predator, more similar to large mustelids than extant canids, likely hunting small prey like hypertragulids. Although the habitat of M. coryphaeus would have been cooler and more open than the dense closed-canopy forests of the Eocene, enough vegetation cover was still present in the Oligocene for ambush hunting to remain a successful strategy.

Non-technical Summary
Living members of the dog family, including wolves, foxes, and our own household pets, are well-adapted for running fast and far, with long legs and stabilized joints. These skeletal adaptations appear in many fossil relatives of dogs, especially in the last 15 million years when grasslands became more dominant on the landscape. But what did the earliest members of the dog family look like? Mesocyon coryphaeus is an early relative of modern dogs that lived in the Pacific Northwest of North America approximately 30 million years ago. Although this species has been known from skulls and teeth for over a century, the skeleton of Mesocyon has been essentially unknown through this time. A spectacular fossil of Mesocyon was discovered by John Day Fossil Beds National Monument staff in the late 1980s. After over 500 hours of preparation work on and off throughout the following decades, the near-complete skeleton of this animal was fully uncovered in 2022. This skeleton is close to a coyote in size but has short, robust limbs and relatively flexible joints, lacking the running adaptations seen in modern dogs. The shape of the skeleton suggests that Mesocyon was an ambush predator, hunting more like modern cats than modern dogs. The habitat in which Mesocyon lived would have had enough vegetation to hide and get close to potential prey. Although larger than earlier dog-relatives, Mesocyon was small enough to survive off of small mammals, like the rodents and mouse deer that lived alongside it.

Figure 1.
(1) Left lateral skeletal outline of Mesocyon coryphaeus reconstructed from JODA 3366. The black outline is a rough approximation of the soft tissue extent drawn directly from the skeletal and has not been generated from precise musculature reconstruction. (2) Left lateral view of cranial material from JODA 3366. The cranium and mandible remain in articulation. The auditory bullae are ossified, visible just posterior to the mandibular joint. Note the atlas and anterior half of the axis in the block of matrix posterior to the skull. Abbreviations: NS, neural spine; TP, transverse process.

Figure 2.
Cervical and pre-diaphragmatic thoracic vertebrae from JODA 3366 (Mesocyon coryphaeus). (1) Dorsal and (2) left lateral views of the posterior half of the axis (top), C3, and C4 (bottom); note the anterior portion of C5 remains articulated with C4 but is only visible in lateral view. (3) Dorsal and (4) left lateral views of the posterior half of C5 (top), C6, C7, and T1 (bottom). (5–7) Left lateral views of isolated pre-diaphragmatic thoracic vertebra of indeterminate position. (8) Dorsal and (9) left lateral view of T10, the last pre-diaphragmatic vertebra. Abbreviations: C, cervical vertebra; CN, centrum; NS, neural spine; POZ, postzygapophysis; PRZ, prezygapophysis; T, thoracic vertebra; TP, transverse process.

Figure 3.
Post-diaphragmatic vertebrae of JODA 3366 (Mesocyon coryphaeus). (1) Left lateral view of articulated section of the vertebral column from the diaphragmatic vertebra (bottom left) to the anterior half of L4 (top right). (2) Left lateral view of posterior half of L4 through L7. (3) Left lateral and (4) dorsal view of sacrum, rendered from CT scan. (5) Dorsal view of proximal-most caudal vertebrae, with more anterior oriented toward the top of the page. (6) Left lateral and (7) dorsal view of the distal-most caudal vertebra preserved with the specimen with zygapophyses intact. Abbreviations: AN, anapophysis; CA, caudal vertebra; CN, centrum; L, lumbar vertebra; NS, neural spine; POZ, postzygapophysis; PRZ, prezygapophyses; RF, rib facet; S, sacral vertebra; SF, sacral foramina; SW, sacral wing; T, thoracic vertebra; TP, transverse process.

Figure 4.
Axial elements from JODA 3366 (Mesocyon coryphaeus). (1) Manubrium in ventral view with anterior end pointed to the top of the page. (2) Dorsal, (3) lateral, and (4) ventral views of baculum. (5–7) Representative ribs with heads intact. Abbreviations: RF, rib facet; UG, urethral groove.

Figure 5.
Forelimb elements of JODA 3366 (Mesocyon coryphaeus). (1) Posterior and (2) lateral views of the left scapula, highlighting overall shape of the scapula and height of the spine. (3) Distal and (4) lateral views of the right scapula, highlighting the shape and size of the glenoid fossa and acromion. Right humerus from a (5) proximal, (6) posterior, (7) medial, and (8) anterior view. (9) Medial and (10) anterior views of left ulna and radius. Abbreviations: AC, acromion; CM, capitulum; CP, coracoid process; DP, deltopectoral crest; EF, epicondylar foramen; GF, glenoid fossa; GT, greater tubercle; HH, humeral head; HO, hereditary osteochondroma, ISF, infraspinous fossa; LSC, lateral supracondylar crest; LT, lesser tubercle; MC, metacromion; OF, olecranon fossa; OP, olecranon process; RN, radial notch; SL, semilunar notch; SS, scapular spine; SSF, supraspinous fossa; STY, styloid process; TR, trochlea.

Figure 6.
Manus elements from JODA 3366 (Mesocyon coryphaeus). Proximal views of carpal elements: (1) left cuneiform, (2) left unciform, (3) left scapholunar, and (4) right pisiform. Dorsal views of carpal elements: (5) left cuneiform, (6) left unciform, (7) left scapholunar, and (8) right pisiform. Dorsal views of metacarpals with proximal to the left of the page: (9) left V, (10) left IV, and (11) right III. (12) Lateral view of ungual with break at distal end, dashed lines indicate missing portion of ungual. (13) Dorsal view of a proximal phalanx.

Figure 7.
Hindlimb elements from JODA 3366 (Mesocyon coryphaeus). (1) Lateral view of left pelvis rendered from CT scan. (2) Patella from anterior view. Right femur from (3) distal, (4) anterior, (5) lateral, and (6) medial views. (7) Lateral view of proximal right fibula. (8) Lateral view of distal right fibula. Right tibia from (9) anterior and (10) lateral views. Abbreviations: AT, acetabulum; CDS, caudal dorsal iliac spine; FH, femoral head; GL, gluteal fossa; GTR, greater trochanter; ISS, ischiatic spine; IST, ischiatic tuberosity; LCD, lateral condyle; LTR, lesser trochanter; MCD, medial condyle; MM, medial malleolus; OB, obturator foramen; PG, patellar groove; TC, tibial crest; TF, trochanteric fossa; TTR, third trochanter.

Figure 8.
Pes elements from JODA 3366 (Mesocyon coryphaeus). (1) Ventral view of right astragalus; note the broken sustentacular facet of the calcaneum remains articulated with the sustentacular facet of the astragalus. (2) Dorsal view of left tarsals and metatarsals; the labeled diagram of the tarsals is not to scale. (3) Lateral view of left tarsals in block with plantar towards the right of the page; the labeled diagram is not to scale. (4) Right calcaneum in dorsal view with distal towards the bottom of the page. Abbreviations: AEF, astragalar ectal facet; AS, astragalus; ASH, astragalar head; CEF, calcaneal ectal facet; CL, calcaneum; CT, calcaneal tuber; CU, cuboid; CUF, calcaneal cuboid facet; IC, intermediate cuneiform; LCN, lateral cuneiform; MCN, medial cuneiform; NV, navicular; PT, peroneal tubercle.

Kort AE, Cavin J, Wang X.
Postcrania and locomotor function of Mesocyon coryphaeus (Canidae, Carnivora) from the Arikareean of North America.
Journal of Paleontology. Published online 2026:1-18. doi:10.1017/jpa.2026.10232

Copyright: © 2026 The authors.
Published by Cambridge University Press on behalf of Paleontological Society. Open access.
Reprinted under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license (CC BY 4.0)

The significance of this fossil does not depend on Mesocyon coryphaeus having been a direct ancestor of modern dogs. Evolution is a branching process, not a ladder, and most species that have ever lived belonged to branches that eventually ended. Mesocyon represents one such evolutionary experiment: a successful, coyote-sized predator that retained the short limbs, flexible joints and partly heel-down posture of earlier canids while becoming larger and more specialised for a meat-based diet.

Its combination of characteristics is exactly what descent with modification predicts. It remained recognisably a canid because it inherited its basic anatomy from canid ancestors, yet it differed from both earlier and later members of the family as its lineage adapted to its particular environment and way of life. It was neither an arboreal forest-dweller like the earliest canids nor a long-legged pursuit hunter like most living ones, but a terrestrial ambush predator occupying an intermediate ecological and anatomical position.

Creationists may respond that it was “still a dog”, as though that somehow counts against evolution. In fact, that is precisely the point. Evolution does not predict that a canid should suddenly produce something that is no longer a canid; it predicts inherited similarities accompanied by accumulated differences. The fossil record shows those differences appearing in a chronological sequence as forests gave way to woodland, shrubland and eventually open grassland, with canid limbs, feet and joints changing accordingly.

Nor can this history be compressed plausibly into a few centuries following a mythical global flood. The three great canid radiations overlap across tens of millions of years in repeatedly dated geological formations. Entire subfamilies diversified into numerous ecological forms, declined and became extinct before the modern canine radiation spread across the world. That is a history of population divergence, environmental adaptation, competition and extinction—not the hurried sorting of supposedly immutable “kinds” after disembarking from a wooden boat.

JODA 3366 also reminds us that extinction is permanent. When the hesperocyonine branch disappeared, its distinctive forms and ways of life disappeared with it; evolution did not recreate them because evolution has no foresight, plan or preferred destination. Creationism can do little more than label Mesocyon a dog and declare the matter closed. Evolution explains what kind of dog it was, how it moved, how it hunted, where it belongs in the family tree—and why nothing quite like it exists today.

Advertisement

Amazon