You'll remember me when the west wind moves
Among the fields of barley
You can tell the sun in his jealous sky
When we walked in fields of gold.
Among the fields of barley
You can tell the sun in his jealous sky
When we walked in fields of gold.
Gordon Sumner
Sung by Eva Cassidy"
Sung by Eva Cassidy"
Where did wild barley get some of its genetic information? From relatives of millet, apparently. That answer poses a rather specific problem for creationists who insist that adding information to a genome requires an intelligent designer. In a paper published in Nature, Jia-Wu Feng and colleagues identified 611 genes across the wild barley genomes they examined that appear to have come from another branch of the grass family. The theory of evolution gave the researchers a way both to spot these genes and to work out where they came from.
The reasoning begins with a prediction. If a gene has passed from parent to offspring down the barley lineage, its sequence should generally resemble the corresponding gene in close barley relatives more than it resembles one in a distant grass. What caught the researchers’ attention were sequences in wild barley whose closest matches lay among millet relatives. Their distribution across the barley family points to horizontal gene transfer — DNA crossing from one lineage into another, where subsequent generations can inherit it. The donor grasses already possessed the sequences. What was new was the genetic information available to the barley plants that acquired them. Many of these genes are transcribed, meaning that the plants make RNA copies of them. Whether any give their recipients an advantage remains an open question.
Horizontal transfer was only one part of the history the team recovered. Comparisons across the genus Hordeum also revealed traces of ancient interbreeding between species. And even where the genes encoding proteins had changed little, the stretches of DNA controlling when and how strongly those genes are switched on had often evolved much faster. A creationist can, of course, credit a designer with the whole arrangement. What does that tell us about which grasses donated the DNA, or where in the barley family we should look for its descendants?
There is a smaller irony here for anyone who believes barley was created for our benefit. An ear of wild barley breaks apart when ripe, scattering the very grain a farmer wants to gather. It is an excellent way for a grass to sow its own seed. Turning it into a dependable harvest took generations of farmers whose harvesting and sowing favoured plants that held on to their grain. It should not have been beyond the wit and capability of a creator god to create a crop which didn't need generations of selection to make it fit for purpose. The people who deserve the credit for that improvement were working in the fields of the ancient Near East, and the effects of their selection can still be read in the barley genome.

































