A flat-topped mesa photographed during geological fieldwork in Western Australia.
Photograph: B. Ware.
How do you tell when Earth began to recycle its crust on a planetary scale, given that the recycling itself destroys much of the evidence? One clue survives even when a rock melts. The new rock that crystallises from the melt can inherit a distinctive mixture of lead isotopes from its source. That gives geologists a way to trace the history of crust far older than the rock they hold in their hands.
In a paper published in Proceedings of the Royal Society A, Dr Janne Liebmann of Curtin University and colleagues traced one such signature through rocks from around the world. They found that crust formed about four billion years ago supplied material for successive generations of younger rocks. For roughly a billion and a half years, the same chemical inheritance kept turning up. Then, about 2.5 billion years ago, the trail ends. Across the regions sampled, the team could find no trace of that distinctive signature in younger rocks.
The authors interpret its disappearance as evidence of a change in the scale of crustal recycling. Ancient crust that had repeatedly melted and cooled in much the same place could now be carried away and mixed with other material, as happens on Earth today. Exactly when the first plate moved remains an open question. What these rocks help us to recognise is when the consequences of large-scale recycling became apparent around the world.
For young-Earth creationists, the awkward detail is the interval between the two dates. By the time that lead signature disappeared, the crust that gave rise to it had already undergone some 1.5 billion years of reworking. A recent global Flood offers no explanation for why successive generations of igneous rock should inherit the same chemical signature, or why that inheritance should cease at much the same point on different continents. Even the process that reshapes our planet today has a history far longer than the few thousand years biblical literalists allow for the planet itself.








































