The skulls of a human (left) and a Neanderthal (right).
Credit: Philippe Psaila/Science Photo Library
Neanderthals disappeared as a distinct population about 40,000 years ago, yet a trace of their ancestry can still be measured in the brains of people alive today. That poses a rather awkward question for anyone who takes Genesis as human history. If we all descend exclusively from a man made from dust and a woman fashioned from his rib — a female clone of Adam, as it were — how did so many of us come to inherit part of our DNA from Neanderthals?
Human evolution supplies an answer. When groups of Homo sapiens dispersed from Africa into Eurasia, they met Neanderthals and had children with them. Some of those children had descendants of their own, among them many people of non-African ancestry today. Biologists call this pattern reticulate evolution. Two branches of the human family tree had grown apart for hundreds of thousands of years, then some of their descendants brought those branches together again.
Hugo Zeberg and Svante Pääbo have now traced one small piece of that inheritance to four missing DNA letters near DAAM1, a gene involved in brain development. They found the deletion in all five high-quality Neanderthal genomes they examined. In living people, each inherited copy was associated, on average, with about 0.85 cubic centimetres less tissue in a region of the occipital lobe, the part of the brain at the back of the head involved in vision. The researchers describe their findings in PNAS.
Anyone tempted to read a smaller brain region as a sign of lower intelligence will find little encouragement in the results. The researchers found little or no association with general cognitive ability. They also found that people who carried two copies of the variant had nearly ten per cent lower odds of schizophrenia. These figures describe averages across groups. What makes the finding remarkable is that we can follow a genetic legacy from encounters between two ancient human populations all the way to a measurable difference on a modern brain scan. Where, in the genealogy of Adam and Eve, is there room for those other ancestors?
What else have we inherited from Neanderthals? When Neanderthals and Homo sapiens had children together, their descendants inherited different versions of genes the two populations already shared. Some of those versions, called alleles, still travel together in stretches of DNA recognisable in living people. Whether one of these stretches is beneficial or detrimental can depend on something as specific as which virus a person encounters.
One stretch of DNA, opposite effects. A Neanderthal-derived stretch of chromosome 3 is associated with a higher risk of severe COVID-19, including respiratory failure. Yet carriers of the same stretch had about a quarter lower risk of acquiring HIV in a separate study. One clue is that carriers produce less of a receptor called CCR5, which many strains of HIV use to enter immune cells. The distinction matters here. One study measured how ill people became after infection, the other their likelihood of acquiring a different infection in the first place. COVID-19 study · HIV study.
An antiviral defence on chromosome 12. A different stretch of Neanderthal DNA is associated with a lower risk of severe COVID-19. Researchers traced much of that protection to a variant of OAS1 that affects which form of an antiviral enzyme the body produces. The protective variant is older than the split between the two human lineages. Some people of European ancestry inherited it through Neanderthals, while many people of African ancestry inherited it independently. The same useful allele has reached living people by two different routes. Study in Nature Genetics.
Pregnancy and the progesterone receptor. Progesterone helps maintain the lining of the womb during pregnancy. In a British study, women who carried a Neanderthal-derived version of its receptor gene, PGR, reported less bleeding in early pregnancy and fewer miscarriages. That suggests a possible reproductive benefit, although the study could not establish how much of the difference the receptor itself explained. Study in Molecular Biology and Evolution.
A sharper response to a pinprick. The gene SCN9A encodes a sodium channel that helps sensory nerves transmit pain signals. In an experiment with Colombian volunteers, researchers first sensitised a patch of skin with mustard oil. It then took less pressure from a pinprick for participants carrying Neanderthal variants to feel pain. Whether that sensitivity helped their ancestors avoid further injury is an intriguing question. What the experiment actually measured was the threshold at which a particular stimulus began to hurt. Study in Communications Biology.
Behind the rather dry term introgression lies a simple human fact. Somewhere in Eurasia, Neanderthals and members of our own species had children, and some of those children went on to have children of their own. We shall never know their names. Yet tens of thousands of years later, geneticists can recognise a stretch of DNA they passed down and relate it to a small, measurable difference in the brains of living people.
There is a lesson here for anyone tempted to rank our extinct relatives by the shape of their skulls. The Neanderthal variant near DAAM1 is associated with a slightly smaller region at the back of the brain, yet the researchers found little or no association with general cognitive ability. The same variant, when inherited from both parents, was associated with lower odds of schizophrenia. Which of those observations would entitle us to call one version of the gene an improvement on the other?
For biblical literalists, the difficulty begins long before anyone puts a volunteer in a brain scanner. By the time a young-earth chronology gets round to creating Adam from dust and Eve from his rib, Neanderthals had already been extinct as a distinct population for more than 30,000 years. By then, too, some of their DNA had long since passed into the ancestors of people alive today. Genesis gives us a solitary founding couple. Our genomes preserve something the authors of Genesis had no means of knowing — the family histories of people whose ancestors had gone their separate ways and whose children brought them together again.
Advertisement
All titles available in paperback, hardcover, ebook for Kindle and audio format.
Prices correct at time of publication. for current prices.














No comments :
Post a Comment
Obscene, threatening or obnoxious messages, preaching, abuse and spam will be removed, as will anything by known Internet trolls and stalkers, by known sock-puppet accounts and anything not connected with the post,
A claim made without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. Remember: your opinion is not an established fact unless corroborated.