Europe’s prehistoric past refuses to fit into the cramped timetable of biblical literalism. Long before anyone wrote the Genesis stories, communities were migrating, mixing with established populations, building networks and negotiating wealth and power over many generations. A new study of Corded Ware burials in what is now Czechia adds revealing detail to that history: a history reconstructed from graves, artefacts and ancient DNA, rather than imposed upon the evidence by an ancient genealogy.
The paper, Cooperation and Competition: Changes in Wealth, Power, and Patrilines in the Czech Corded Ware Culture, by Mikkel Nørtoft and Adam B. Rohrlach, is published in the Journal of Neolithic Archaeology investigates more than 300 graves from Bohemia and Moravia, combining measures of burial expenditure with previously published biological and genetic evidence to examine how social differences developed.
The communities concerned had substantial ancestral connections with migrants from the Pontic steppe, north of the Black Sea. These migrants mixed with populations already living in Central Europe. This was neither the beginning of European settlement nor the first arrival of farming and livestock husbandry. Ancient-DNA research documents earlier farming populations in Europe some 8,000–7,000 years ago, themselves distinct from the hunter-gatherers who preceded them. The steppe migrations therefore belong within a much deeper history of population movements and mixture, not a story of an empty continent awaiting the descendants of one recently rescued family.
The social picture is also more interesting than a simple tale of invaders bringing a ready-made hierarchy. The authors suggest that early Bohemian communities emphasised cooperation, with relatively modest differences in burial wealth. Later phases show greater competition and, eventually, possible signs of more persistent inequality. Richly furnished children’s graves raise the possibility of inherited advantage, although the researchers stress that more genetic evidence is needed to establish the family-level relationships involved. Burial display is evidence to interpret, not a direct inventory of everything a person owned.
Here, then, is a European past with depth, diversity and change: populations with different histories meeting, forming communities and reshaping their social arrangements. The new paper concerns prehistoric inequality, rather than a test of Genesis, but its wider context exposes the weakness of treating a regional origin myth as the history of all humanity. Archaeology is recovering the lives and relationships that biblical literalism has to squeeze into a story far too small to contain them.
Before the Corded Ware^ Europe’s deeper ancestry. The Corded Ware communities did not enter an empty Europe, and they were not its first livestock keepers. Their emergence belongs to a much longer history of migration, population mixture and cultural change. Three broad ancestral contributions help explain much of this history, although each included regional variation and earlier mixtures of its own.The paper in Journal of Nealithic Archaeology was accompanied by a University of Copenhagen press release:
- Hunter-gatherers: Europe before farming
Modern humans lived in Europe tens of thousands of years before agriculture. These populations were neither uniform nor static: Ice Age climatic changes, migrations and population replacements repeatedly altered their distribution. Ancient genomes from Ice Age Europe reveal a complex history stretching far beyond the roughly 6,000 years allowed by familiar young-Earth chronologies. Later European hunter-gatherers contributed ancestry to farming populations as the two came into contact.
- Early farmers: an earlier migration from Anatolia
Farming reached south-eastern Europe about 8,500 years ago and spread across the continent over subsequent millennia. Ancient DNA establishes a strong connection between many of these early farmers and populations in Anatolia and the Aegean. They brought crops and domestic livestock, while their descendants mixed to varying degrees with local hunter-gatherers. The genetic links between Aegean and European farmers therefore document a major movement of people long before the Corded Ware expansion.
- Steppe-related populations: a later contribution
During the third millennium BCE, people with substantial ancestry related to pastoralist populations of the Pontic–Caspian steppe, north of the Black and Caspian seas, spread into Central and northern Europe. Their arrival helped shape Corded Ware communities through mixture with existing populations. Ancient-DNA research identified a large steppe-related contribution to sampled Corded Ware individuals. These pastoralists were themselves descended from earlier, genetically differentiated populations: they did not represent an unmixed ancestral “race”.
A timeline that cannot be compressed into Genesis
How can DNA distinguish these histories?
Approximate date Event or claim Tens of thousands of years ago Modern human hunter-gatherers live in Europe through changing Ice Age environments. About 6500 BCE onwards Farming communities become established in south-eastern Europe; agriculture subsequently spreads farther across the continent. 4004 BCE Ussher’s proposed date for Creation — a biblical calculation, not an archaeological event. About 2900–2300 BCE The Bohemian Corded Ware burial sequence discussed in the new study. 2348 BCE Ussher’s proposed date for Noah’s Flood, falling within the closing part of that burial sequence. Archaeological dates are approximate and regional developments were not simultaneous. The biblical dates shown belong to Ussher’s chronology; other literalist calculations differ.
Researchers compare genetic variants across many parts of the genomes of ancient individuals from different places and periods. Patterns of shared ancestry help reveal population relationships and mixture. These comparisons are combined with radiocarbon dates and archaeological contexts: the result is a history anchored to actual human remains, rather than inferred solely from people living today. Ancestry labels describe statistical relationships to sampled populations; they do not automatically identify someone’s language, culture or ethnicity.
A Y-chromosome haplogroup tells a much narrower story. Most of the Y chromosome passes from father to son, so it traces one paternal line, not the full ancestry of an individual. A paternal lineage can become common while ancestry from many other lines remains in the population. Consequently, the dominance of one Y-chromosome lineage in a cemetery does not demonstrate descent of the entire community from one recent family. It may reflect reproductive differences, migration, social organisation or who received burial there.
The central distinction: Europe’s ancestry includes genuine connections with Anatolia and other parts of south-western Asia, as well as with the steppe. What the evidence contradicts is the compression of these distinct populations and successive movements into a recent dispersal from Noah’s family. Farmers were already living in Europe before Ussher’s supposed Creation, and the later Corded Ware communities had their own developing history across the supposed Flood.
Archaeologists shed new light on wealth and status among Europe's early herders
A new study by researchers from the University of Copenhagen and the Max Planck Institute indicates that early herding communities in Central Europe only gradually developed social inequality – it was not imported by the steppe migrants
How unequal were prehistoric societies? And how can archaeologists measure wealth in cultures that left behind no written records, no tax registers and no census data?
A researcher from the University of Copenhagen has developed a multi-proxy method called QuantWealth that uses archaeological evidence from graves to reconstruct social status, wealth display, and inequality thousands of years ago.
In a new study published in Journal of Neolithic Archaeology, the method was applied to almost 300 4-5,000-year-old graves in present-day Bohemia. The researchers compared the analyses of the graves with genetic ancestry and Y-chromosome patterns of the skeletal remains to track paternal lineages, including pathologies, age, and gender to give unprecedented detail to the story of the so-called Corded Ware culture.
The researchers found that social inequality emerged gradually in Bohemia over several centuries following migrations from the steppe. These migrations spread early Indo-European dialects across Europe, but, at least in Bohemia, inequality was not deeply entrenched:Archaeologists have long debated whether steppe populations migrating across Europe from Ukraine brought with them a highly unequal social system and patriarchy. Our results suggest a much more dynamic picture, where social differences developed gradually. Achieving status through life-actions appears to have been more important than through inheritance, at least during the first 400 years.
Mikkel Nørtoft, lead author
Section for Prehistoric Archaeology
Saxo Institute
University of Copenhagen Copenhagen, Denmark
A society in transition
Mikkel Nørtoft and his colleague Adam B. Rohrlach analysed 296 burials from the Corded Ware culture in Bohemia dating between approximately 2,900 and 2,300 BCE.Following a few harsh years of “dark sun” clouded by a devastating volcanic eruption 2,900 BCE, the earliest herder communities, settling in Bohemia around 2,900-2,700 BCE, seem to have focused mostly on building social cohesion across this new network of migrants in Central Europe. In Bohemia, they did this through shared burial rituals, and building earthen mounds, but with few grave goods.
.Mikkel Nørtoft.
Wealth differences were small, mostly age-related, and power seems to have been distributed across multiple steppe-derived lineages, with little gender inequality.
Increased competition and inequality
Over time, circa 2,700-2,500 BCE, however, funerary competition in Bohemia intensified after a new lineage appeared. The researchers found increasing concentrations of prestige items, meat offerings, expanding exchange networks, and growing gender inequality. Adult men in particular became associated with more richly furnished graves, and younger adults became most frequent in the graves, but without clearly increasing signs of violence in skeletal trauma.
In the final phase, roughly 2,500-2,300 BCE, we see a few rich displays of family wealth through children, and the previously new lineage now dominated the burial record. So maybe the new lineage had gained the most followers and power through the competitive burial parties, and their descendants were now competing among themselves. The few rich child graves and this prevailing lineage could indicate more inherited wealth and emerging traits of persistent inequality. Ethnographic parallels could also support the idea that parents adorned their children with ornaments to increase their social value in future marriage exchange. Brides often moved into the husband’s household in Corded Ware societies, and bridewealth or dowry is preserved in early Indo-European vocabulary, and historically common in Indo-European societies.
Mikkel Nørtoft.
This could be exemplified in one particularly rich female child grave in this late phase from the site Čachovice, the richest among all Bohemian graves in the study. This grave also included an extremely rare copper neck ring, a widespread upper-class symbol (known as “torcs”) in the later European Bronze and Iron Ages.
According to the researchers, these developments suggest growing social competition and the possible emergence of more durable forms of inequality among late Corded Ware communities.
Whether this development shows the first small steps to long-standing family dynasties documented later in the Bronze Age will require more data on both the Corded Ware Culture and the related Bell Beaker Culture who replaced them in Central Europe.
We now have a correlation between changing Y-haplogroup lineages and unequal burial wealth display in one region, but we need more DNA data to confirm this at the family level, and elsewhere.
Mikkel Nørtoft.
The study also shows how combining DNA, archaeology, and language can enrich narratives about social changes in the past.
Publication:
For biblical literalists, the difficulty is not simply that these people lived a long time ago. It is that they belonged to a European history already rich in migrations, population mixture and cultural development. The steppe-related ancestors of Corded Ware communities encountered people whose farming traditions stretched back thousands of years, and whose hunter-gatherer ancestors reached much further into the past. Although the Corded Ware burials themselves post-date Ussher’s proposed Creation, the wider history behind them extends well beyond it. Archaeology and ancient DNA reveal successive populations with distinguishable histories, not a recent dispersal of humanity from one small family in the Middle East.
The Flood chronology creates an even more immediate problem. The Bohemian burial sequence examined here spans approximately 2900–2300 BCE, placing Ussher’s supposed worldwide catastrophe of 2348 BCE towards its end. Across those centuries, the researchers identify changing patterns of burial expenditure, social competition and paternal lineages. A literal global Flood would require the destruction of these communities, followed by their replacement with descendants of Noah’s family. That is a radically different history from the one the evidence supports. Moving the Flood date within a young-Earth timetable does not remove the need to demonstrate such a worldwide demographic catastrophe and subsequent repopulation.
There is also the inconvenient survival of the evidence itself: graves, human remains, pottery and their archaeological associations, sufficiently preserved for researchers to reconstruct changes over generations. Preservation of an individual grave would not, by itself, disprove a flood; local floods can bury and sometimes preserve archaeological material. But a catastrophic inundation of the entire planet is a different proposition. It requires a corresponding worldwide geological record and an archaeological rupture consistent with the destruction of every human community outside the Ark. No credible geological or archaeological evidence establishes such an event. Evidence of particular regional floods cannot be converted into evidence that the whole Earth was submerged at once.
This study also illustrates how science advances. The researchers question a simple model in which steppe migrants arrived with an already entrenched system of inequality, proposing a more gradual and locally contingent development. They distinguish observations from interpretations and acknowledge where additional DNA evidence is needed. Such uncertainties concern the details of prehistoric social organisation; they do not make a biblical catastrophe a viable alternative. Science can revise its account because it answers to evidence. Biblical literalism demands that the evidence answer to a predetermined story. The Corded Ware people left a history in their graves; creationism can accommodate it only by rewriting that history to protect the myth.
Advertisement
All titles available in paperback, hardcover, ebook for Kindle and audio format.
Prices correct at time of publication. for current prices.














No comments :
Post a Comment
Obscene, threatening or obnoxious messages, preaching, abuse and spam will be removed, as will anything by known Internet trolls and stalkers, by known sock-puppet accounts and anything not connected with the post,
A claim made without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. Remember: your opinion is not an established fact unless corroborated.