Fig. 1
(a) Sampling locations in the Clarion Clipperton Zone highlighting the BGR and GSR polymetallic nodule exploration contract areas, and the box core sampling locations within each area during the SO268 expedition in 2019. Reference-site polygons indicate nearby undisturbed baseline areas within the respective BGR and GSR exploration contract areas. Box cores outside these polygons represent pre-impact samples from the associated trial or dredge sites and were analysed according to their respective site category. Comparative datasets from other cruises and sampling gears are summarised in Supplementary Table 8. Maps created in QGIS. (b) Photographs of the surface of each box core from which the nodules were collected (box core surface area = 2,500 cm²).
If every creature was created for the benefit of humans, why conceal entire communities inside the cracks of mineral nodules several kilometres beneath the Pacific Ocean? It is an awkward question for a worldview which treats humanity as the purpose of the natural world. These organisms have their own requirements for survival and reproduction, but their existence comes with no label explaining what service they were supposedly designed to provide for us.
A new study published in Scientific Reports on 11 November 2026 reveals how polymetallic nodules in the Clarion–Clipperton Zone of the central Pacific provide a distinctive habitat for tiny organisms. The researchers found communities dominated by nematodes — roundworms — and copepods — small crustaceans — occupying the nodules’ crevices. DNA analyses showed that these communities differed from those in nearby sediments. These apparently unpromising mineral lumps contain an additional dimension of deep-sea biodiversity.
Polymetallic nodules occur at depths of around 4,000–6,000 metres and grow over millions of years, often by only a few millimetres per million years. Their cracks and cavities provide living spaces for organisms smaller than a millimetre. Across 244 nodules, the team recorded more than 4,100 inhabitants, with as many as 245 in a single nodule. There is also an obvious problem here for young-Earth creationism: the formation of these habitats requires a geological history vastly longer than the few thousand years permitted by a literal reading of Genesis.
From the perspective of ecology and evolutionary biology, however, the finding makes good sense. A seabed with hard surfaces, sheltered crevices and soft sediment offers more kinds of living conditions than an expanse of mud alone. Different organisms can exploit different combinations of space, food and shelter. Over generations, natural selection can favour traits suited to particular conditions; where populations diverge sufficiently, ecological opportunities can also contribute to the evolution of new species. None of this requires the resulting organisms to be useful, visible or even known to humans.
There is an important distinction here: this study documents distinct communities, not the process of speciation within the nodules. Their composition could reflect colonisation and the filtering of existing species by local conditions, as well as a longer evolutionary history. The discovery is therefore consistent with the expectations of evolutionary ecology, rather than direct evidence that these particular species evolved inside these particular mineral structures. The opportunities are newly documented by researchers; they are not necessarily newly created in nature.
Nor does the argument depend on proving that these organisms can never benefit humanity. The point is that their distribution has an intelligible ecological explanation which does not require human benefit as its organising principle. Indeed, our interest in the metals creates a troubling irony: extracting resources valuable to us could destroy the habitats of creatures supposedly put there for us. Evolution requires no such purpose to explain their existence. The inhabitants of these hidden worlds are getting on with their lives, whether or not humanity finds a use for them.
Ecological niches^ why a lump of rock can support a different community from the surrounding mud. To a human observer, a mineral nodule on the deep-sea floor might look like little more than a stone lying in mud. To an organism smaller than a millimetre, however, its surfaces, cracks and cavities offer a very different environment from the surrounding sediment. Differences on this tiny scale can help explain why neighbouring habitats support different communities.The paper in Scientific Reports was discussed in an accompanying account from MARUM at the University of Bremen:
A habitat is an address; a niche is a way of life
A habitat is the place or environment in which an organism lives. An ecological niche encompasses the conditions and resources it needs, together with its interactions with other organisms. These include what it eats, the physical conditions it tolerates, and its relationships with competitors, predators and prey. Two species can occupy the same habitat while using different resources or feeding in different ways.
A niche is therefore more than an empty space waiting for an occupant. It describes how an organism lives within its environment. When a new habitat becomes available, it can offer ecological opportunities, but whether organisms exploit those opportunities depends on their existing characteristics, their ability to reach it and their interactions with other species.
Small structures, different living conditions
Polymetallic nodules introduce hard surfaces and internal crevices into a seabed otherwise dominated by soft sediment. At the scale of their tiny inhabitants, these structures can alter access to shelter, space and food. Such physical variety is called habitat heterogeneity: an environment contains several kinds of living space rather than being uniform throughout.
In the study of nodules from the Clarion–Clipperton Zone, the researchers found that nematode and copepod communities recovered from nodule crevices differed from those in nearby sediments. This demonstrates a difference in community composition. It does not, by itself, identify every environmental factor responsible for that difference.
Communities can differ before new species evolve
Distinct communities do not necessarily require species to evolve in the places where we find them. Existing species may arrive from elsewhere, but only some will possess characteristics that allow them to survive and reproduce under local conditions. This process is known as environmental filtering. Dispersal, chance events and interactions between species can also influence which organisms become established.
For example, an organism already able to move through narrow spaces might colonise a crevice successfully, while another species might remain more abundant in soft sediment. The resulting difference could arise without either species undergoing a new evolutionary change. Ecologists therefore distinguish the assembly of a community from the evolutionary origin of its members.
Where evolution comes in
Over generations, natural selection can favour inherited variations that improve survival and reproduction in particular conditions. If populations experience different selective pressures, they may diverge. Where sufficient reproductive isolation develops, divergence can lead to speciation. However, neither adaptation nor speciation is an automatic consequence of every new habitat: gene flow, population history and other factors influence the outcome.
The nodule study is consistent with the expectation that different environments can support different assemblages of organisms. It does not demonstrate that the inhabitants originated within the nodules, establish when their adaptations evolved, or show speciation in progress. Those questions would require additional evidence.
New to science does not mean new to nature
As the MARUM account explains, polymetallic nodules develop over millions of years. Their inhabitants are being investigated now, but the habitats themselves have a much longer history. Discovering an ecological opportunity is not the same as witnessing its creation.
None of these explanations requires an organism to serve a human purpose. Ecology asks how it obtains resources and interacts with its surroundings; evolutionary biology asks how its inherited characteristics arose and changed. Its usefulness to humans is a separate question.
Brief glossary
- Meiofauna:
- Very small animals, usually studied using defined sieve-size ranges, that live in sediment or other small spaces. They include many nematodes and copepods.
- Habitat:
- The place or environment in which an organism lives.
- Ecological niche:
- The conditions, resources and biological interactions associated with an organism’s way of life.
- Environmental filtering:
- The process by which local conditions favour the establishment of species with suitable characteristics.
- Adaptation:
- An inherited feature shaped by natural selection because it improves survival or reproduction in a particular environment; also the evolutionary process producing such features.
- Speciation:
- The evolutionary formation of distinct species.
Hidden Worlds in the Deep Ocean
New Study Shows That Polymetallic Nodules Are Important Habitats for Tiny Marine OrganismsIn the extreme depths of the Pacific Ocean, there are small, metal-bearing formations that are far more than just valuable sources of raw materials. A new study published in the journal Scientific Reports shows that so-called polymetallic nodules serve as specialized habitats for tiny organisms. An international team led by Dr. Tanja Stratmann from MARUM – Center for Marine Environmental Sciences at the University of Bremen, Dr. Coral Diaz-Recio Lorenzo, and Dr. Sabine Gollner from NIOZ – the Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research – was able to demonstrate that the crevices and pores within these nodules harbor a unique community of life that differs significantly from the animals found in the surrounding seafloor. Since polymetallic nodules take millions of years to form, commercial mining would permanently destroy this unique habitat. This makes the findings important for planning protected areas in the deep sea.
A Tiny Home in the Deep Sea
A crustacean of the species Munidopsis sp. among polymetallic nodules in the Clarion-Clipperton Fracture Zone (CCZ). The wrinkled structure of the nodules, which were examined in detail in the study, is clearly visible. The photo was taken during Expedition SO268 using the ROV KIEL6000.Photo: ROV Kiel 6000, GEOMAR, Kiel
Polymetallic nodules are fist-sized, dark lumps of iron and manganese oxides that grow extremely slowly over millions of years – often just a few millimeters per million years. At depths of 4,000 to 6,000 meters, they form rare hard surfaces on the otherwise soft, muddy seafloor. The researchers investigated who lives in the tiny cracks and cavities of these nodules.
In our study we show that the sizes of cracks inside the nodules are large enough to provide home to animals that are smaller than a millimeter in size.
Dr. Tanja Stratmann,co-lead author
Department of Ocean Systems
NIOZ–Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research
Landsdiep, ‘t Horntje (Texel)
The Netherlands.
To find these organisms, the scientists used, among other things, box corers and diving robots to collect samples from the Clarion-Clipperton Zone in the central Pacific. The nodules were carefully dissected in the laboratory to extract the organisms from the crevices.
Unique Communities and Concrete Numbers
What makes this research unique is the finding that the nodules not only provide a surface but also create a three-dimensional habitat through their internal structure. An analysis of 244 nodules revealed a total of 4,139 individual animals. On average, 17 individuals lived in each nodule, although in one instance as many as 245 animals were found in a single nodule.
The crevices in the polymetallic nodules function as small shelters and provide home to animals that we do not encounter in the soft sediment of the seafloor.
Dr. Coral Diaz-Recio Lorenzo, co-lead author
Department of Ocean Systems
NIOZ–Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research
Landsdiep, ‘t Horntje (Texel)
The Netherlands.
Although the number of animals in the polymetallic nodules is lower than in the surrounding sediment – for roundworms (nematodes), it corresponds to about 10%, and for small crustaceans (copepods), about 25% of the total in the sediment – it is nonetheless significant for the entire ecosystem. It is particularly important that the species composition differs. Genetic analyses showed that the communities within the nodules were very similar across wide distances (up to 1,000 km) but differed significantly from the animals in the sediment.
Risks Associated with Deep-Sea Mining
These findings have significant societal implications, as polymetallic nodules are considered a target for industrial deep-sea mining due to the metals they contain, such as nickel, cobalt, and copper. However, since the nodules take millions of years to form, their extraction would result in the loss of this unique habitat and all associated life. One example is the single-celled species Thurammina sp. 1, which is particularly common in the nodules. This species appears to be perfectly adapted to the sheltered spaces within the nodules. If the nodules were extracted, there would be no replacement for these specialized inhabitants. Such a loss would be permanent on geological time scales, as the nodules do not regrow within human lifetimes but need millions of years.
Our findings point out that commercial mining may result in an irreversible loss of undescribed and unique biodiversity associated to nodules. This needs to be considered in environmental management of deep-sea mining.
Professor Sabine Gollner, co-author.
Department of Ocean Systems
NIOZ–Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research
Landsdiep, ‘t Horntje (Texel)
The Netherlands.
This new knowledge underscores that the protection of the deep sea must take into account not only large animals but also microscopic inhabitants. Future research must now determine whether the loss of these local communities would lead to the global extinction of certain species or whether the animals could survive in other areas. These findings are essential for planning protected areas and assessing the environmental impacts of deep-sea mining projects. To this end, Dr. Tanja Stratmann is currently on an international research expedition to the Clarion-Clipperton Zone to further study the polymetallic nodule ecosystem. These and other follow-up studies are independently funded as part of the JPIOcean projects MiningImpact 2 and 3.
Publication:
Graphical summary of the microbial communities on polymetallic nodules.Credit: Dr. Coral Diaz-Recio Lorenzo.
For young-Earth creationism, the most immediate difficulty lies in the nodules themselves. These mineral structures grow over millions of years, often adding only a few millimetres per million years. They cannot be fitted into a history in which the entire Universe appeared a few thousand years ago, nor does invoking a recent global flood explain their prolonged growth. Creationists need an evidence-based account of how these particular structures formed, not simply an assertion that a catastrophe can accomplish whatever their preferred chronology requires.
The microfossils preserved within the nodules add a biological history to that geological one. The researchers identified remains including diatoms, radiolarians, foraminifera and sponge spicules within the mineral matrix and along crack walls. These require a history of organisms living, dying and having their remains incorporated into the nodules. There is an important qualification: some material may have entered through cracks later, or been reworked from older sediment, so the fossils do not provide a simple date for the beginning of nodule growth. That qualification illustrates the care with which science distinguishes evidence from inference. It does not make the nodules’ million-year formation timescale disappear.
The living communities present a different difficulty for the claim that everything was created for human benefit. Why populate microscopic crevices kilometres beneath the Pacific with organisms whose existence remained unknown to us until modern exploration revealed them? Their possible indirect benefits to humanity are not the issue; nothing in their distribution requires human usefulness as an explanation. Ecological differences, colonisation and the evolutionary histories of the organisms provide a coherent framework for understanding why nodule crevices support communities different from those in surrounding mud. The study does not demonstrate speciation inside the nodules, but its findings fit comfortably within evolutionary ecology without requiring an undisclosed divine purpose.
These inconspicuous lumps therefore confront creationism with both deep time and a world that does not revolve around us. They preserve traces of past life while providing habitats for life today, and our appetite for their metals now threatens habitats that cannot be replaced on human timescales. Science uncovers this history by examining structures, identifying organisms and testing explanations, while acknowledging what remains uncertain. A creationist account that begins with a fixed biblical timetable must instead find ways to explain the evidence away. Even in the cracks of a stone on the Pacific seabed, nature has a history far richer than the mythology allows.
Advertisement
All titles available in paperback, hardcover, ebook for Kindle and audio format.
Prices correct at time of publication. for current prices.















No comments :
Post a Comment
Obscene, threatening or obnoxious messages, preaching, abuse and spam will be removed, as will anything by known Internet trolls and stalkers, by known sock-puppet accounts and anything not connected with the post,
A claim made without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. Remember: your opinion is not an established fact unless corroborated.