This article appeared in the on-line version of New Scientist today. I find the headline disturbingly misleading. Even cursory reading of the article shows that Varga and Weins' findings point to the possibility that ray-finned fish may all share a common ancestor which evolved in fresh water.
If true, this is interesting but nothing really surprising. After all, why should a founder species for a major group NOT evolve in fresh water rather than the sea, and why should it not then expand into a salt-water environment and radiate there into the many species we have today?
But, the idea that a founder species evolved in fresh-water (note, NOT on land as the headline says, but in water) and then radiated, is a far cry from the idea conveyed in the headline that 'most' fish evolved that way. And nowhere is it suggested that ANY fish evolved on land as most people would understand the term 'land'.
I'm surprised and disappointed to see this over-simplification and misleading approach to science in a respected science magazine.
Most fish in the sea evolved on land - life - 08 February 2012 - New Scientist:
'via Blog this'
Wednesday, 8 February 2012
2 comments:
Obscene or obnoxious messages, preaching and advertising spam will be removed.
If possible, please provide a citation for any substantive claims or at least give a cogent reason why you accept it as factual. A quote from a book held to be holy by a minority of the world's people is not a scientific argument.
Whilst you are entitled to your opinion, you are not entitled to have it regarded as established fact needing no supporting evidence or justification. Don't be surprised if you are called on an unsubstantiated claim.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
ShareThis
I looked over that article every which way, and have no clue where "land" came from. Did they mean that freshwater is land? Strange article.
ReplyDeleteMichael.
DeleteI was puzzled (and disappointed) by that too. I suspect it was a misjudged attempt to sell the article.
I wonder how long it will take for creation 'scientists' to ridicule science and claim scientists now believe fish evolved from land animals, so the idea that life evolved in the sea and then migrated onto land has been 'overthrown'.