Tuesday, 22 December 2020

Evolution News - Using the TOE to Understand Biology

Genomic study of fleas finds them to be related to scorpionflies

Image: Shutterstock
December: fleas study | News and features | University of Bristol

Three of the more ludicrous claims from those who want to attack the current consensus of evolutionary biologists, that evolution is gene-centred, are refuted, quite incidentally and without effort or intent, by a team of biologists from Bristol University, in an open access paper published in the journal, Palaeoentomology a couple of days ago.

The study resolves the long-standing problem in taxonomy of where exactly fleas should be placed in the tree of life, since they are not morphologically easily assigned to any of the other major insect taxons, so have been given a taxon of their own with no clear evolutionary relationship to the other Insecta taxons. The team resolved the issue by examining more than 14,000 protein-coding genes of fleas. These showed an evolutionary relationship to a rare group of insects called scorpionflies. Fleas diverged from this sap-sucking group some 290 to 165 million years ago when they adopted a parasitic, blood-sucking life-style. The Bristol University press release explains:
A study of more than 1,400 protein-coding genes of fleas has resolved one of the longest standing mysteries in the evolution of insects, reordering their placement in the tree of life and pinpointing who their closest relatives are.

The University of Bristol study, published in the journal Palaeoentomology, drew on the largest insect molecular dataset available. The dataset was analysed using new statistical methods, including more sophisticated algorithms, to test all historically proposed hypotheses about the placement of fleas on the insect tree of life and search for new potential relationships.

The findings overturn previously held theories about fleas, the unusual anatomy of which has meant that they eluded classification in evolutionary terms. According to the authors of the study, contrary to popular belief, fleas are technically scorpionflies, which evolved when they started feeding on the blood of vertebrates sometime between the Permian and Jurassic, between 290 and 165 million years ago.

The closest living relatives of fleas are the members of the scorpionfly family Nannochoristidae, a rare group with only seven species native to the southern hemisphere. Unlike the blood-thirsty fleas, adult nannochoristid scorpionflies lead a peaceful existence feeding on nectar.

“Of all the parasites in the animal kingdom, fleas hold a pre-eminent position. The Black Death, caused by a flea-transmitted bacterium, was the deadliest pandemic in the recorded history of mankind; it claimed the lives of possibly up to 200 million people in the 14th century,” says lead author and undergraduate student Erik Tihelka from the School of Earth Sciences.

“Yet despite their medical significance, the placement of fleas on the tree of life represents one of the most persistent enigmas in the evolution of insects.”

It used to be thought that all blood-feeding parasitic insects began life as either predators or by living alongside vertebrate hosts in their nests. In actual fact, blood feeding can evolve in groups that originally fed on nectar and other plant secretions.

“It seems that the elongate mouthparts that are specialized for nectar feeding from flowers can become co-opted during the course evolution to enable sucking blood,” says Mattia Giacomelli, a PhD student at the University of Bristol who participated in the study.

Previous studies had suggested a connection between fleas and anatomically unusual groups of scorpionflies, but their exact relationships remained unresolved. The mystery was prolonged by the fact that flea genomes underwent rapid evolution, which makes reconstructing ancient evolutionary relationships challenging. Moreover, the nannochoristids are a quite rare and little-studied group that only occurs in New Zealand, southeastern Australia, Tasmania, and Chile, so they are easy to overlook.

“The new results suggest that we may need to revise our entomology textbooks. Fleas no longer deserve the status of a separate insect order, but should actually be classified within the scorpionflies,” says Chenyang Cai, associate professor at the Nanjing Institute of Geology and Palaeontology (NIGP) and a research fellow at the University of Bristol specialising on Mesozoic insects.

“We have exceptionally preserved fossil fleas from the Jurassic and Cretaceous. In particular, some Jurassic fleas from China, about 165 million years old, are truly giant and measure up to two centimetres. They may have fed on dinosaurs, but that is exceedingly difficult to tell. What is more interesting is that these ancient fleas share important characters with modern scorpionflies.”

The three claims, two ludicrous ones by Creationists and a slightly less ludicrous one by a small group of dissident biologists that this paper refutes are:
  1. Evolution can't proceed on the basis of genetic mutations since all mutations are harmful, and the more recent but equally ludicrous one, invented by Michael J Behe to replace the failed intelligent [sic] design argument - that all genetic changes must be 'devolutionary' [sic] changes (from a perfectly created initial magic creation). Fleas are phenomenally successful, compared to the scorpionflies they diverged from and show a high degree of adaptation to their environment, often being highly species-specific. There was even a 'giant' flea, some 2 cm long, now extinct, that probably parasitised dinosaurs!
  2. The Theory of evolution is a theory in crisis which is about to be overthrown by one which complies with a literal reading of the Bronze-Age origin myths related in the Bible. There is no evidence of such a crisis in this paper nor in the methodology which applies the TOE to a practical problem of taxonomy, showing again how the theory is the fundamental underpinning theory of modern biology which no serious professional biologist even questions any more, let alone sets out to prove or disprove. That nonsensical claim has been repeatedly made since the 1950's by creationists. It's looking as likely as the end of the world they keep predicting any day now, real soon!
  3. That genes cannot be the locus of evolutionary change since selection occurs at the level of the phenotype. Yet this study shows how genes can be arranged in a hierarchy which maps directly onto the tree of life and so forms the basis of taxonomic classification far more accurately than does phenotypic morphology. This would only hold true if evolution and divergence were occuring at the genetic level, not at the phenotypic expression of those genes.
Without an understanding of the genetic basis for evolution and divergence, the precise taxonomy of fleas would still be unresolved.

submit to reddit

No comments :

Post a Comment

Obscene, threatening or obnoxious messages, preaching, abuse and spam will be removed, as will anything by known Internet trolls and stalkers, by known sock-puppet accounts and anything not connected with the post,

A claim made without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. Remember: your opinion is not an established fact unless corroborated.

Sady, the spammer is back so you'll need to sign on to post comments.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...
Web Analytics