F Rosa Rubicondior: Creationism in Crisis - A Dinosaur Fossil In The 'Wrong' Place - But Not What Creationists Hoped For

Tuesday 2 April 2024

Creationism in Crisis - A Dinosaur Fossil In The 'Wrong' Place - But Not What Creationists Hoped For

Duckbill dinosaur discovery in Morocco – expert unpacks the mystery of how they got there

Here's something to excite creationists!

It's a fossil out of place!

Sadly though, it's not out of place in the geological column - which would falsify evolution - but out of place geographically. It's the fossil of a duck-billed dinosaur in Morocco, North Africa, but it's closest relatives appear to be from Europe, which was a long sea voyage away at the time and no obvious island chain for them to island hop on.

And to add to the mystery, the European duck-billed dinosaurs didn't evolve in Europe, but in North America, so they must have got to Europe somehow.

When the news from science is relentless in its refutation of creationism, it would have been nice to find something to give the poor beleaguered fools a few crumbs of comfort, but it was not to be. This one is just as relentless s all the others.

In the following article, reprinted from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license, Nicholas R. Longrich, Senior Lecturer in Paleontology and Evolutionary Biology, Life Sciences, University of Bath, Bath, Somerset, UK, explains how they got to Europe and then ended up in North Africa. His article has been reformatted for stylistic consistency:
Duckbill dinosaur discovery in Morocco – expert unpacks the mystery of how they got there
A herd of the duckbill Minqaria bata wander along the shore of what is now Morocco.
Raul Martin
Nicholas R. Longrich, University of Bath

Why are fossils of duckbill dinosaurs, a North American family, found in North Africa?

Dinosaurs couldn’t just walk there. Sixty-six million years ago, when duckbills suddenly appear in Africa’s fossil record, the world’s land masses formed a series of islands. A seaway divided eastern and western North America; Europe was an archipelago. South America, India, Australia and Madagascar were all island continents, surrounded by ocean.

Africa was an island too – it was impossible to walk there from North America. And yet, somehow, we’ve now found fossils of duckbill dinosaurs in Morocco.
The world at the end of the Cretaceous, 66 million years ago.
By R. Blakey.
Continental breakup

Go far enough back in time, 200 million years ago, and the continents are all united into one land mass, the vast supercontinent of Pangaea. At this point, you could’ve walked between North America and Africa. But this doesn’t explain the mystery of Africa’s duckbills. Pangaea broke up tens of millions of years before duckbills evolved, and by 100 million years ago, Africa had split off from South America and became isolated.

The first duckbill dinosaurs evolved in North America around 90 million years ago – after all the land connections were broken, when Africa was isolated by hundreds of kilometres of open sea.

But five years ago, our team of palaeontologists found the jawbones of a tiny dinosaur in Morocco. These fossils come from a little, pony-sized animal we named Ajnabia odysseus, the first African duckbill. Somehow, little Ajnabia‘s ancestors got to north Africa.

Now, we’ve found new fossils in Morocco which deepen the mystery. They not only confirm that duckbills colonised Africa, they show duckbills rapidly diversified once they got there.

More little duckbills

One of these fossils is the partial skull of a new species, Minqaria bata (Arabic for “beak” and “duck”). Minqaria’s teeth are broader and blunter than Ajnabia’s, and the jaws have a sinuous shape, suggesting it filled a distinct ecological niche. Minqaria also preserves a braincase. The skull bones are tightly knit as in adults, so despite its small size, Minqaria was fully grown.
Minqaria skull
Nick Longrich

North American and Asian duckbills were giants: they grew up to 15 metres long and could weigh 10 to 20 tonnes. Minqaria was just a few metres long and weighed maybe 250kg; Ajnabia was similar in size. Two bones found a few kilometres away – a humerus and a femur – come from bigger duckbills, 5-6 metres long, hinting at a third, larger species.
A herd of Minqaria bata inspects the mosasaur Thalassotitan.
Raul Martin
It seems that once duckbills arrived in Africa, they quickly diversified, exploiting open niches. They may have specialised in the small herbivore niches, where they faced less competition from the giant, long-necked titanosaurian sauropods.
Morocco dinosaur fauna
Nick Longrich.
Curiously, Minqaria’s skull resembles that of French and Spanish duckbills, confirming our hunch that the Moroccan duckbills are related to the European species. It appears duckbills emigrated from Europe, but how?

Hundreds of kilometres of ocean separated Africa and Europe in the Cretaceous. Emergent islands may have helped to bridge the gap, but there’s little evidence for a land bridge. Duckbills couldn’t walk to Africa. That leaves us with an ocean crossing.

This seems unlikely, but as Sherlock Holmes said:

When you have eliminated the impossible, then whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth.

There are several ways animals might cross an ocean. Some animals can float long distances. Tortoises float surprisingly well, and can survive months without food or water.
This tortoise survived months at sea, with barnacles growing on its body as it drifted.
Catharine Muir.
In 2004, a tortoise washed ashore in Tanzania after drifting from the Seychelles, 700km away. The animal had been at sea so long, it was covered in barnacles – yet, astonishingly, it was alive. That’s probably how tortoises colonised the Galapagos.

Sometimes animals hitch a ride on floating vegetation. In 1995, after a hurricane hit the Caribbean, a group of iguanas washed up on Anguilla, clinging to debris. They probably came from Guadeloupe, 300km away.

Many species swim well. Deer swim frequently, and have been seen swimming up to 25km between islands in the Great Lakes in North America. Elephants can swim almost 50km to reach offshore islands. That’s probably how deer and elephants got to Crete and Sardinia during the Pleistocene.

One way or another – floating, rafting, swimming – duckbills crossed water to Africa. Possibly a herd was washed out to sea, then drifted and swam with the currents. And while full-grown duckbills would have been too big to raft, tiny hatchlings could have ridden on floating vegetation. However it happened, duckbills crossed the sea. And since Europe was also isolated from Asia by a seaway in the Cretaceous, they may have first had to cross water to get to Europe.
Distribution of duckbill dinosaurs in North Africa and Europe.
Nick Longrich
This sort of thing may be far more common than we think. A number of other perplexing dinosaur occurrences hint at oceanic dispersals. The spread of titanosaurs from South America to North America, and the spread of another tribe of duckbills, the kritosaurs, into South America probably involved ocean crossings.

The big picture

Why does it matter if dinosaurs crossed oceans?

It matters because it shows how rare, extreme, improbable events can have a big impact on evolution. Charles Darwin thought everyday processes drove evolution – processes like competition, predation, mate choice. And given time, everyday events will add up to create huge changes. But it’s also the case that if you wait long enough, very weird, unlikely things happen. Given time, highly improbable events can become highly probable, even inevitable. Over vast spans of time, freak events – asteroid impacts, “Snowball Earth” glaciations, massive volcanic eruptions and oceanic crossings – shape evolution. Not just dinosaur evolution, either.

Human evolution could be one of those astonishingly rare occurrences, or maybe the result of a series of highly improbable events. Curiously, when our primate ancestors came from Asia to Africa 50 million years ago, it was still an island. The arrival of primates in Africa, which began the evolution of monkeys, apes and finally Homo sapiens, was also due to an incredibly lucky ocean crossing. A small group of primates was swept out the sea. Against all odds, they survived, perhaps clinging to rafts of floating trees. Then, improbably, they washed up in Africa, survived, multiplied – and evolved into us. What the fossils tell us is that evolution isn’t just about survival of the fittest. As much as anything, it’s about the survival of the luckiest. The Conversation
Nicholas R. Longrich, Senior Lecturer in Paleontology and Evolutionary Biology, Life Sciences at the University of Bath, University of Bath

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Published by The Conversation.
Open access. (CC BY 4.0)
Although creationists can glean a few crumbs of comfort from the fact that a duck-billed dinosaur has been found far away from where it should have been, as a non-aquatic species, what they can't get any comfort from is the fact that this dinosaur lived in what is now North Africa some 66 million years before Earth existed according to creationist dogma.

It'll be interesting to see what misuse frauds such as Ken Ham, Kent Hovind and his sidekick, little Eric Hovind, et al. make of this piece of news, if they don't decide to ignore it altogether and rely on their dupes never reading any real science.


What Makes You So Special? From The Big Bang To You

How did you come to be here, now? This books takes you from the Big Bang to the evolution of modern humans and the history of human cultures, showing that science is an adventure of discovery and a source of limitless wonder, giving us richer and more rewarding appreciation of the phenomenal privilege of merely being alive and able to begin to understand it all.

Available in Hardcover, Paperback or ebook for Kindle


Ten Reasons To Lose Faith: And Why You Are Better Off Without It

This book explains why faith is a fallacy and serves no useful purpose other than providing an excuse for pretending to know things that are unknown. It also explains how losing faith liberates former sufferers from fear, delusion and the control of others, freeing them to see the world in a different light, to recognise the injustices that religions cause and to accept people for who they are, not which group they happened to be born in. A society based on atheist, Humanist principles would be a less divided, more inclusive, more peaceful society and one more appreciative of the one opportunity that life gives us to enjoy and wonder at the world we live in.

Available in Hardcover, Paperback or ebook for Kindle


Thank you for sharing!

submit to reddit

No comments :

Post a Comment

Obscene, threatening or obnoxious messages, preaching, abuse and spam will be removed, as will anything by known Internet trolls and stalkers, by known sock-puppet accounts and anything not connected with the post,

A claim made without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. Remember: your opinion is not an established fact unless corroborated.

Web Analytics