Cross section of a dog's heart showing heartworm.
The University of Sydney
An international team of researchers led by scientists at the University of Sydney, NSW, Australia, have just published a paper in Communications Biology which reshapes our understanding of a widespread canine parasitic nematode, the heartworm, Dirofilaria immitis. It is also more bad news for creationists, and for the intelligent design cult in particular.
In particular, the team have shown that this parasite has probably been co-evolving with dogs since before they were domesticated. It had previously been assumed that human activity was responsible for the spread of these worms.
Applying all the criteria traditionally cited by ID creationists as ‘proof’ of intelligent design, any designer of this parasite emerges as a grotesque malevolence determined to make dogs suffer. There is also the problem, for ID creationists, of clear evidence of a co-evolutionary arms race — the hallmark of mindless evolution and the antithesis of intelligent design.
Heartworms are complex organisms, with a complex life cycle involving both the primary host — dogs — and a vector — mosquitoes — all of which must be present for the parasite to survive, thus conforming neatly to Michael J. Behe’s supposed ‘evidence for intelligent design’: irreducible complexity. There is also evidence of resistance both to the dog’s immune system and, more recently, to the veterinary drugs used to treat the infection, conforming equally well to William A. Dembski’s proposed ‘evidence for intelligent design’: complex specified genetic information. So, within the ID paradigm, the conclusion becomes unavoidable — heartworms have been intelligently designed and are being actively redesigned in order to continue making dogs suffer and to stay ahead in their arms race with veterinary science.
But of course, the biological evidence shows that these parasites are the product of a co-evolutionary process in which neither magic nor intent were involved. Nematode genes have no concern for the suffering they cause, nor for whether their host lives or dies, so long as it survives long enough to pass the parasites on to the next generation of dogs.
Although the evidence conforms exactly to what the Theory of Evolution predicts — and evolution remains the most parsimonious explanation, absolving any deities of responsibility — for some inexplicable reason the ID cult would prefer people to believe that these, and thousands of other parasites, were the handiwork of their favourite deity, who thus emerges as a divine malevolence; a complete contrast to the supposedly omnibenevolent god of the holy books that creationists worship.
Heartworms and Their Life Cycle.The work of the team led by Professor Jan Šlapeta of the Sydney School of Veterinary Science, Faculty of Science, The University of Sydney, together with Stephen R. Doyle of the Wellcome Sanger Institute, Hinxton, Cambridgeshire, UK, is the subject of a news release from the University of Sydney via EurekAlert!.Heartworms (Dirofilaria immitis) are parasitic nematodes that primarily infect dogs, but can also infect cats, foxes, wolves, and occasionally humans. Adult worms live in the pulmonary arteries and heart, where heavy infections can cause heart failure, lung disease, reduced exercise tolerance, and ultimately death if untreated.
Transmission requires a mosquito vector. Microfilariae (larval heartworms) circulate in the blood of an infected dog and are ingested by a feeding mosquito. Within the mosquito they undergo several developmental stages over 10–14 days, becoming infective third-stage larvae. When the mosquito bites another host, these larvae are deposited on the skin and enter through the bite wound.
Inside the new host, the larvae migrate through tissues for several months, eventually reaching the heart and pulmonary arteries, where they mature into adults. After mating, females release new microfilariae into the bloodstream, completing the cycle. The entire process from infection to reproductive adulthood typically takes six to seven months.
This complex dependence on both vertebrate host and insect vector, together with rapid evolutionary responses to host immunity and veterinary drugs, makes heartworms a textbook example of host–parasite co-evolution and evolutionary arms races — and a particularly clear illustration of how intricate biological systems arise without foresight, intent, or design.
Ancient ‘spaghetti’ in dogs’ hearts reveals surprising origins of heartworm
Global DNA study rewrites the evolutionary history of canine disease
Research led by the University of Sydney is reshaping scientific understanding of one of the world’s most widespread canine parasites, suggesting heartworm disease has a far deeper and more complex evolutionary history than previously believed – including a possible ancient origin of Australian heartworms linked to dingoes.
The findings have significance for developing treatments given the rise in drug resistance to the disease.
In a global genome-wide study of canine heartworm parasites, researchers analysed more than 100 heartworm genomes collected from dogs and wild canids across multiple continents. The findings challenge the long-held assumption that heartworm spread largely through recent, human-mediated movement of domestic dogs.
Instead, the study points to a new evolutionary paradigm, where ancient canid hosts such as wolves and dingoes played a pivotal role in shaping the global distribution of heartworms over tens of thousands of years.
The paper is published today in Communications Biology.
Heartworm disease, caused by the parasite Dirofilaria immitis, is transmitted by mosquitoes and can be fatal for dogs if left untreated. Adult worms – often described as looking like strands of spaghetti – can grow up to 30 centimetres long and live in the blood vessels of the heart and lungs.
One of the most intriguing findings relates to Australia. Genetic signatures in Australian heartworms suggest they may share ancestry with parasites from Asia. This raises the possibility that heartworm could have arrived in Australia with the continent’s first dingoes, which are believed to have migrated from Asia thousands of years ago.
However, the researchers caution that the evidence is not conclusive. An alternative explanation – that heartworm was introduced to Australia more recently, following European colonisation – cannot yet be ruled out.
While our data suggest an ancient link between Australian and Asian heartworms, the sample size means we need to be careful about drawing firm conclusions. What we can say with confidence is that heartworm evolution is far older and more complex than a simple story of parasites hitchhiking with modern dogs.
Professor Jan Šlapeta, senior author
Sydney School of Veterinary Science
Faculty of Science
The University of Sydney
Sydney, NSW, Australia.
The international team used whole-genome sequencing to compare heartworms from different regions, allowing them to reconstruct population histories and track how parasites diverged over time. By examining patterns across continents, the researchers identified distinct regional heartworm populations, shaped by the movements and isolation of ancient canids during ice ages and interglacial periods.
Lead author Dr Rosemonde Power, who completed her PhD at the University of Sydney and is now based at Stockholm University, said the findings overturn long-standing assumptions in parasitology.
For decades, we assumed heartworms were spread mainly through recent human activity. What we’re seeing instead is evidence of deep co-evolution between heartworms and their canine hosts, even before humans were part of the picture.
Dr Rosamonde Power, first author.
Sydney School of Veterinary Science
Faculty of Science
The University of Sydney
Sydney, NSW, Australia.
Now: Department of Zoology
Stockholm University
Stockholm, Sweden
The research also has important implications for animal health today, particularly as drug resistance to heartworm treatments emerges in parts of the world.
Understanding where heartworms come from and how different populations are related helps us respond more effectively to disease and drug resistance. Heartworms are not the same everywhere, and local history matters.
Professor Jan Šlapeta.
The authors emphasise that while the study analysed over 100 genomes, further sampling – particularly from under-represented regions – will be needed to refine timelines and test competing hypotheses, including the origins of heartworm in Australia.
Still, the study marks a significant step forward in understanding the ancient, global journey of one of dogs’ most dangerous parasites – and the long evolutionary history hidden within that unsettling spaghetti in a dog’s heart.
Publication:
This work leaves creationists with yet another uncomfortable dilemma. Either these parasites are the product of blind evolutionary processes, exactly as the Theory of Evolution predicts, or they must be the deliberate creations of a designer who specialises in inflicting prolonged suffering on animals. There is no third option that preserves both scientific credibility and theological comfort.
An added embarrassment for creationists is that the researchers themselves show no trace of doubt about the framework within which these results make sense. Throughout the paper, evolutionary theory is used openly and confidently to interpret patterns of genetic divergence, host adaptation, drug resistance and long-term co-evolution. This is not evolution invoked tentatively or as a last resort, but evolution functioning precisely as a mature, predictive, and indispensable scientific theory.
This directly contradicts a claim creationists have repeated for more than half a century: that evolution is in crisis, unsupported by genetics, and clung to only for ideological reasons. In reality, evolutionary theory continues to guide productive research, generate testable predictions, and explain complex biological systems in ways that no supernatural alternative has ever matched.
As with so many parasites, pathogens and evolutionary arms races, heartworms are quietly doing what they have always done — evolving, adapting, and exploiting ecological opportunities without foresight or intent. The only people left struggling to explain them are those who insist on inserting design where the evidence points relentlessly to evolution.
Advertisement
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
All titles available in paperback, hardcover, ebook for Kindle and audio format.
Prices correct at time of publication. for current prices.
No comments :
Post a Comment
Obscene, threatening or obnoxious messages, preaching, abuse and spam will be removed, as will anything by known Internet trolls and stalkers, by known sock-puppet accounts and anything not connected with the post,
A claim made without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. Remember: your opinion is not an established fact unless corroborated.