Stratigraphic context of the Kommagnes Charnia specimen. A, photograph (facing north) of the eastern part of the cliff, with the site of the float block marked by a star. B, stratigraphic log of the left side of A, marking the stratigraphic range from which the float block could have originated.
Creationists have a major problem with the so-called Cambrian Explosion, some 535 million years ago. On the one hand, they insist it was a sudden moment of creation in which multiple different body-plans were magically created without ancestry; on the other hand, they deny there was any history before 6,000-10,000 years ago. Clearly both views can't be right; However, both views can be wrong.
And for creationists of both camps, the Ediacaran presents and even bigger problem: not only did it precede the Cambrian, but it shows that complex body-plans had already evolved. This problem just got a lot more acute with the discovery of an exceptionally well-preserved fossil in a sheep field in Arctic Norway, in approximately 560 million year old rocks, of a fossils of Charnia, a branching, frond-like organism that lived during the Ediacaran Period, well before the Cambrian began. These organisms inhabited an ancient seabed hundreds of millions of years before the supposed ‘Creation Week’ of young-Earth creationism.
As a paper published in Palaeontology by researchers led by Dr Yorick Veenma reports, this is the first confirmed fossil of Charnia to be found in Scandinavia. It was found alongside other Ediacaran fossils and is a rare three-dimensional specimen which preserves anatomical details normally obscured in flattened impression.
Despite its superficial resemblance to a fern, Charnia was no plant. It belonged to the rangeomorphs, an extinct group generally interpreted as early animals, although their precise relationships to living animal groups remain debated. We need not claim that Charnia was a direct ancestor of any particular Cambrian animal to appreciate its significance: large organisms with elaborate body structures already existed before the diversification that creationists so often misrepresent as an instantaneous act of creation.
The Norwegian specimen also illustrates how much the fossil record depends on the circumstances of preservation. Its three-dimensional form reveals angular ridges, or ‘keels’, along its branches that are not apparent in more familiar flattened specimens. The researchers attribute this preservation to a short journey within a sediment-laden underwater flow, followed by burial in its clay-rich deposit. An unusual combination of conditions preserved details that would otherwise have been lost.
Naturally, creationists may seize on the rapid burial and attempt to recruit it as evidence for Noah’s Flood. But rapid burial is a recognised geological process, and identifying it does not establish a worldwide catastrophe, and nor were any later organisms found buried in this formation. A local underwater sediment flow is entirely sufficient to explain this deposit; invoking a biblical deluge adds nothing to the explanation and does nothing to reconcile its Ediacaran age with a chronology of only a few thousand years.
What emerged from this Norwegian sheep field is therefore another glimpse of a long-vanished world: a world with its own communities, unfamiliar organisms and geological processes, already ancient long before the first humans began inventing creation stories.
The Ediacaran Biota^ Complex Life Before the Cambrian. When did they live?The paper in Palaeontology was accompanied by a news release from the University of Cambridge:
The Ediacaran Period lasted from approximately 635 to 539 million years ago, immediately before the Cambrian. Its best-known communities of large, mostly soft-bodied organisms flourished during the later part of that interval. The Norwegian Charnia fossils, approximately 560 million years old, therefore predate the beginning of the Cambrian by about 21 million years.
What were the Ediacaran biota?
“Ediacaran biota” is a collective description, not the name of a single evolutionary lineage. Ediacaran ecosystems included microbes, algae and early animals, together with unusual extinct organisms whose precise relationships remain uncertain. The term biota is therefore more appropriate than fauna, which refers specifically to animals.
Some of these organisms had body structures unlike those of anything alive today. Others preserve evidence of features familiar from later animals, including movement, directional feeding and a recognisable front and back. Their unfamiliar appearance makes classification challenging, but does not make their existence or geological antiquity doubtful.
A very different underwater world
Many Ediacaran communities inhabited seabeds covered by microbial mats: interacting communities of microorganisms that bound the sediment surface together and provided food for some larger organisms. Some inhabitants remained attached to the bottom, while others moved across it. Burrowing and sediment disturbance were generally less extensive than in later marine ecosystems, helping these mat-covered environments persist.
These were functioning communities with different ways of obtaining food and occupying space. They were not simply a collection of incomplete versions of modern animals.
Some representative organisms
Organism Appearance and significance Charnia A frond-like rangeomorph built from repeated branching units. Despite its resemblance to a fern, it was not a plant. Rangeomorphs are generally interpreted as early animals, although their precise position within animal evolution remains debated. Dickinsonia A flattened, oval organism with repeated rib-like units. Evidence from its growth, associated traces and preserved organic molecules supports an animal interpretation. Some specimens are associated with impressions interpreted as successive feeding positions on microbial mats. Kimberella An organism with a recognisable front and back, generally interpreted as a bilaterian animal. Associated scratch marks suggest that it fed by scraping material from the seabed. It is often compared with molluscs, but its exact relationship to them remains uncertain.
Why are their fossils so unusual?
Most of these organisms lacked hard skeletons, so their preservation required favourable conditions. Many fossils survive as impressions or casts that record external shape while revealing little internal anatomy. Microbial mats, rapid burial and early mineral formation could help preserve features that would otherwise disappear during decay.
The Norwegian Charnia specimen is particularly valuable because its three-dimensional preservation reveals angular ridges along its branches that are not apparent in familiar flattened fossils. Such discoveries help scientists distinguish original anatomy from changes caused by burial and fossilisation.
What do they tell us about the Cambrian?
The Ediacaran fossil record demonstrates that large, structurally complex organisms—including animals—existed long before the Cambrian diversification. This does not mean that every Ediacaran species was a direct ancestor of a living animal group. Some belonged to branches that became extinct, and many relationships remain unresolved.
The central point is nevertheless clear: the Cambrian diversification took place in a world that already possessed complex organisms and established ecosystems. It was a major episode in the history of life, not the instantaneous appearance of animals without a preceding evolutionary history.
Glossary
Further reading:
- Biota
- The organisms of a particular region, environment or geological interval.
- Rangeomorph
- A member of an extinct group of Ediacaran organisms characterised by repeated branching structures, often arranged into frond-like bodies.
- Microbial mat
- A community of microorganisms forming a coherent layer on a surface, often binding sediment and influencing its chemistry.
- Trace fossil
- Preserved evidence of an organism’s activity, such as a track, burrow or feeding mark, rather than its body.
- Bilaterian
- An animal belonging to the great evolutionary group whose basic body organisation typically includes left and right sides, a front and back, and an upper and lower surface.
One of the oldest known 3D animal fossils found in Norwegian sheep field
One of the oldest known 3D fossils of an animal has been discovered in a sheep field in the Norwegian Arctic, the first new major site of its kind found in Europe in decades.
The fossil dates from around 560 million years ago, during the Ediacaran Period, when complex forms of life first appeared on Earth. The fossil, known as Charnia, looks more like a fern than anything we would recognise as an animal today.
Charnia did not have a mouth, organs, or any visible means of movement, and was essentially a ‘goo-filled bag’ – like a sedentary jellyfish – however, it is thought to be one of the earliest animals to exist.
Many fossils dating from this period in the Earth’s history are found as flat impressions, like a flower pressed between the pages of a book. However, the new fossil – the first confirmed Charnia find in Scandinavia – is preserved in three-dimensional detail, which is incredibly rare for soft-bodied organisms, especially of this age.
The creature was swept up in an ancient underwater avalanche and quickly buried in the seabed. This filled its body with sediment, while preserving its three-dimensional form. This extraordinary preservation allowed researchers, led by the University of Cambridge, to study it in detail. Their results are reported in the journal Palaeontology.
Thanks to the high-quality preservation, the fossil was found to contain subtle ridges, known as ‘keels’, along each of its branches – a feature that had not been detected in other, flatter fossils.
When you see the same species preserved in a different way, you start noticing properties you hadn’t seen before.
Dr Yorick P. Veenma, lead author
Department of Earth Sciences
University of Cambridge
Cambridge, UK
While Ediacaran fossils have been found in different places worldwide, the discovery of a new location in Finnmark, Norway, suggests that the earliest animals may have been far more widely spread than was previously known, and that other unexplored areas could hold similar surprises.
As scientists, we tend to go to the same well-known sites again and again to look for fossils like these. This find shows that there is still potential for discoveries in less familiar places.
Dr Yorick P. Veenma.
The area of Norway where the fossils were found is near an outcrop where hints of Ediacaran life had been seen before, like strange anchoring structures made by organisms as they attached themselves to the ancient seafloor. However, fossils of the organisms themselves had never been found – until a chance find in a sheep field revealed a rich new seam of fossils. Some rocks had fallen off a cliff, split open, and revealed the Charnia fossil within.
As a fossil record, the Ediacaran has several things working against it, primarily that most organisms were soft-bodied and skeletons hadn’t evolved yet, so that they are harder to preserve. A lot of fossils from the period occur as impressions where they've been squashed down under layers of rock.
Professor Neil Davies, co-author
Department of Earth Sciences
University of Cambridge
Cambridge, UK
This time period also does not have a widespread rock record. Fossils need to be embedded within sedimentary rocks to be found, so if the rocks themselves are less common, then that makes the fossils harder to find. Most Ediacaran fossils come from just a handful of locations, which makes it exciting to find them somewhere new.
Dr Yorick P. Veenma.
In addition to the exquisitely preserved Charnia fossil, the researchers identified several other parts of the fossil ecosystem, and they hope that more will continue to turn up.
There may be a whole undiscovered community of these very early organisms preserved up there. Weird little umbrella-shaped blobs, things that don’t fit with what people know from elsewhere. There are a whole host of different things that were not known before.
Professor Neil Davies.
The researchers say that similar Ediacaran fossils may continue to turn up in unexpected places, and that it’s important to keep searching for new sites, even in areas where no fossils have been found before.
Publication:.
For young-Earth creationism, the difficulty begins with the age of these fossils. Approximately 560 million years ago, organisms such as Charnia were already living in marine communities, growing, reproducing and eventually becoming buried in sediment. Compressing that history into a few thousand years requires the rejection of the geological evidence, not an alternative explanation of it.
The discovery also adds anatomical detail to the substantial fossil record of complex life before the Cambrian. Creationist accounts of the ‘Cambrian Explosion’ commonly depend on portraying it as the instantaneous appearance of animals without predecessors. Yet here is another window into the biological world that preceded it by millions of years. Whether Charnia left living descendants or belonged to an entirely extinct branch does not alter that central fact: animal evolution had a history before the Cambrian diversification.
Nor does rapid burial offer a rescue for the biblical flood narrative. The researchers identify a local sedimentary process capable of transporting and preserving these organisms. Evidence that an underwater flow buried a community is evidence for that event; turning it into a planet-wide deluge requires additional evidence that this discovery does not provide. A mechanism of fossil preservation cannot simply be substituted for the very different claim that the entire fossil record formed during a single year.
There is also a revealing contrast in how new information is treated. Scientists have used this specimen to uncover features hidden in flattened fossils and refine their understanding of an ancient organism. Questions remain, and further discoveries may change the interpretation. That is how an evidence-based account improves. Biblical literalism, by contrast, begins with a fixed conclusion and must find reasons to dismiss whatever refuses to fit. The rocks in a Norwegian sheep field have supplied another fact that refuses to cooperate.
Advertisement
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
Amazon
All titles available in paperback, hardcover, ebook for Kindle and audio format.
Prices correct at time of publication. for current prices.
No comments :
Post a Comment
Obscene, threatening or obnoxious messages, preaching, abuse and spam will be removed, as will anything by known Internet trolls and stalkers, by known sock-puppet accounts and anything not connected with the post,
A claim made without evidence can be dismissed without evidence. Remember: your opinion is not an established fact unless corroborated.