Reconstruction of Purussarus neivensis attacking Pericotoxodon platignathus.
Image: Miguel Hernandez.
If the Young-Earth creationist claim that there was no death, suffering or predation before Eve’s supposed ‘sin’ were true, four fossil specimens preserved in museum collections in Colombia should not exist. They are the remains of large herbivorous mammals bearing punctures and other damage attributed to the teeth of a giant crocodylian—and they are between approximately 10.5 and 16 million years old.
In other words, these fossils are not merely the remains of animals that lived and died millions of years before there were humans to commit any biblical ‘sin’. They preserve physical evidence of animals attacking—or, at the very least, feeding upon—other animals in a functioning predator–prey ecosystem more than a thousand times older than the entire universe imagined by Young-Earth creationists.
The evidence is described by Oscar E. Wilson of the University of Helsinki and Jorge W. Moreno-Bernal in a paper recently published in the Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. The researchers examined four specimens belonging to three species of large, now-extinct South American ungulates from the celebrated La Venta fossil assemblage of Colombia: the toxodontid Pericotoxodon platignathus and the astrapotheres Xenastrapotherium kraglievichi and Granastrapotherium snorki.
The skulls and jaws bear puncture marks and, in some cases, substantial deformation caused by a powerful bite. From the size and shape of the marks, together with the force apparently needed to produce the damage, Wilson and Moreno-Bernal identify the most likely culprit as Purussaurus neivensis, an enormous relative of modern caimans that may have reached about seven metres in length and weighed approximately 1,800 kilograms.
Middle Miocene South America contained an ecosystem unlike anything living today. The continent’s long geographical isolation had allowed native mammals—including toxodontids, astrapotheres, ground sloths and glyptodonts—to diversify independently. Around the immense tropical wetlands lived giant snakes, flightless predatory ‘terror birds’, terrestrial crocodyliforms and several kinds of aquatic crocodylian. Because large mammalian carnivores were comparatively scarce, reptiles such as Purussaurus occupied the major apex-predator niches.
Earlier studies had inferred this ecological role from the animals’ size, anatomy and the composition of the La Venta fauna. The newly reported bite marks provide direct physical evidence that giant crocodylians interacted with—and probably preyed upon—some of the ecosystem’s largest herbivorous mammals. Purussaurus may therefore have helped to regulate herbivore populations, much as large predators influence prey populations in modern ecosystems.
For creationists, the problem could hardly be clearer. These animals lived, competed, killed, fed, reproduced and became extinct millions of years before any known hominin existed, let alone the mythical couple blamed in Genesis for introducing death into the world. Even if an individual bite mark resulted from scavenging rather than an actual attack, that alternative still requires a dead animal, a flesh-eating crocodylian and an established ecological system based partly upon the consumption of carcasses. It offers no refuge for the claim that the pre-Fall world was free from death and carnivory.
